


  
 



|
PERSONAL FINANCE:
SHANBHAG'S WONDERLAND
In and Out of PPF
How you can use withdrawals to axe your tax.
By D Kumar
The Public Provident Fund (PPF) scheme was
always a good scheme for tax-payers. But since 1986, when the premature withdrawal rules
were amended, it has become superlative.
According to the amended rules, beginning the seventh year
from the year of the first contribution, and every year thereafter, you can withdraw 50
per cent of the balance you had in your account four years ago, or one year ago (whichever
sum is less). This, I say, is the best feature of the PPF scheme.
Why? Because, effectively, you can use the withdrawn amount
to reinvest in your PPF account. While the withdrawals would be free of tax, you would get
a rebate on the amount reinvested! (Remember Section 88 of the Income-Tax Act, 1961?)
I said ''effectively'' because you must contribute to the PPF
from your taxable income. So what you can do is to contribute to your PPF account from
your taxable income, exercise the option to withdraw, and use the withdrawn sum to meet
your day-to-day expenses.
Nice, isn't it?
PARTIAL WITHDRAWALS. Now, let me explain
with an example. Assume that you contribute a fixed sum, say, Rs 100, to your PPF account
every year. In the seventh year, you'd notice a strange phenomenon. You would be able to
withdraw as much as Rs 168.72! The next financial year, you would be able to withdraw Rs
238.97! You'd find that, beginning the seventh year, every year until maturity, your net
contribution to PPF would be negative even as you would enjoy the full benefits of the
tax-rebate on your contribution of Rs 100.
There are many investors who shy away from PPF under the
mistaken notion that their funds would be locked up for 16 long years. But that's only the
term of the PPF. Moreover, liquidity is much higher in the case of PPF than, say, National
Savings Certificates.
WHY WITHDRAW? Your PPF account gives you 12
per cent interest, and that is tax-free, whatever the amount. Many investors are so
enthralled by this expression ''tax-free'' that they crave to invest in PPF even beyond
the permissible limit of Rs 60,000 per account per year. And some actually go to the
extent of contributing an additional Rs 30,000 (gift-tax free) to the PPF accounts of
their children or spouse every year!
Such people do not ever take advantage of the premature
withdrawal facility that the scheme provides. Unfortunately, what they do not realise is
that the pure-growth, open-end debt-based instruments of mutual funds give them an
opportunity to earn 14 per cent-plus after-tax income (see Zero Tax Game, BT, April
7,1998).
BOTTOMLINE. The PPF scheme is attractive
only for the tax-rebate available during the year of contribution. Once you have pocketed
the rebate, the best strategy would be to withdraw as much, and as soon, as possible. You
should increase the contributions if and only if they provide additional rebates. But if
you are already contributing Rs 60,000 without depending on withdrawals, I would say
withdraw as much as you can from your PPF account, and put the money in mutual fund
schemes. I assure you, you'd suffer from no withdrawal symptoms. |