


  










|
MARKETING
Lessons In Repositioning BritanniaEat Healthy. Think Better. Buy Britannia. The 80-year-old biscuit king is
reinventing itself. Britannia now wants to become a foods giant, with the newly-added tag
of health and nutrition. What's more, with a clever formula of prices and products, it is
targeting every segment of the Indian market.
By Chhaya
Britannia Rules! A
day before the World Cup Of Cricket 99 began in England on May 14, 1999, one of Britannia
Industries' senior-most marketing managers was spotted at Mumbai's Sahar International
Airport-escorting a gaggle of excited children, all of them sporting Britannia caps,
Britannia T-shirts, and other assorted Britannia paraphernalia. No, he wasn't
test-positioning yet another brand of biscuits on a group of unsuspecting young 'uns in an
airport lounge. Those kids were actually some of the 100 mega-winners of the Britannia
Khao, World Cup Jao contest, being flown off on charters to Old Blighty to watch the
World Cup at Britannia's expense. See Cricket. Sleep Cricket. Eat Only Britannia (sic!).
BRITANNIA'S
FOOD STRATEGIES |
| BISCUITS: Target
customers to capture growth in each category by segmenting the market both along
conventional lines and through segmentation DAIRY: Enter selective segments to establish a presence so
that the portfolio includes premium as well as popular brands
BREAD: Continue with the category
despite being a low-margin market since its presence is a logical extension of its
expertise in bakery products |
After all, the Rs 1,030-crore Britannia had spent a
whopping Rs 10 crore on the bkwcj contest-the single biggest promotion ever in the Indian
marketing history. Instead of concentrating on a few of its biscuit brands, Britannia
included all 16 of them in the 7-level contest it ran, which blocked the air-waves for 13
weeks. The result: 1.60 crore customers actually exchanged 4 empty packs each for the
booklet on cricket that came as the first reward. Make no mistake, though: Britannia's
jump onto the Cup bandwagon was not driven by the herd mentality that spurred marketers to
splurge on cricket promos this year.
Britannia's decision was entirely pre-meditated. Every March,
biscuit sales fall by nearly 30 per cent. It is a seasonal quirk that biscuit-makers like
Britannia have learnt to live with. But, as the run-up to the World Cup began in February,
1999, Britannia saw a golden opportunity to boost its sales this year. And, as it turned
out, the company's volumes did, eventually, grow by 20 per cent between February and
April, 1999, versus the industry's 7 per cent. Imaginative? Yes. Costly? Yes.
Uncharacteristic?
LOOK
BEYOND THE PRODUCT, AT THE CUSTOMER. AND USE KNOWLEDGE TO REPOSITION THE BRAND
The 80-year-old Britannia's biggest problem was that it thought Britannia meant
biscuits to the customer. It actually meant health and nutrition. Eat healthy, Think
Better is a tangible proposition to the customer |
Utterly. Till recently, no one would have associated
such street-savviness with Britannia. The 80-year-old Anglo-Indian corporate citizen was,
well, 80 years old. And it showed. Britannia's biscuit brands, which have enormous equity,
were market-leaders, but lacked magic. Smaller players, like Parle Products, as well as
scores of regional brands were constantly snapping at its heels. While its share in
biscuits-Britannia has held on to 38 per cent of the organised sector's market-hadn't
taken a bashing, the company hadn't been growing it either.
What's more, the Rs 3,500-crore business has been
commoditised, with 65 per cent of the 1 billion biscuits bought every year by Indians
being produced by the small sector. Worse, suddenly, a spate of transnationals broke in
last year: Sara Lee, United Biscuits, Kellogg, and Nestle India. And Britannia, clearly,
could no longer take even its leadership for granted.
Simultaneously, the Bangalore-based boxwallah faced another
challenge: it was over-dependent on one product, with biscuits accounting for 85 per cent
of its turnover last year. Dependence to that degree could have disastrous consequences,
especially in a market where the competition was hotting up. It had happened to
Colgate-Palmolive, whose over-dependence on the oral-care market is threatening its
existence. It could happen to Britannia too.

"Britannia
will now have to decide which part of the businesses it wants to focus on."
Rajeev Bakshi
CEO, Cadbury India |
So, Britannia realised that it would have to both fire
up its marketing strategies in its main line of business, and tap new food categories to
grow in too. One reason why it woke up late was because the company didn't have a proper
parent until the French food and beverages major, Danone, acquired RJR Nabisco's holding
in the company. Only in 1993 did Danone, along with Bombay Dyeing's Nusli Wadia,
consolidate its 44 per cent stake in Britannia, and put in place a stable management, led
by Managing Director Sunil K. Alagh. But now, Alagh realised, the time had come to change
the rules of the game-quickly. His two-pronged agenda:
REINFORCE BRITANNIA'S STRENGTH IN BISCUITS. Swamp
the market by wider and deeper distribution, and differentiate Britannia's products by
re-positioning every brand.
REDUCE BRITANNIA'S DEPENDENCE ON BISCUITS. Diversify
into new businesses, and turn Britannia from a biscuits company into a foods company.
Thus, Britannia wants to stay the market-leader in biscuits,
and be a major player in other businesses too. ''As we enter the New Millennium, the
company's vision,'' explains the dapper, salt-and-pepper-maned Alagh, ''is to ensure that
every third Indian is a Britannia consumer.'' That is, 300 million consumers of
Britannia's biscuits, bread, butter, cheese, and snacks. And, who knows, perhaps
yoghurt-and, of course, milk.
IDENTIFY
RELATED PRODUCT CATEGORIES WHERE THE BRAND'S USP IS RELEVANT. AND DIVERSIFY INTO THEM
Britannia's foray into dairy products and snack foods isn't just a response to a
market-opportunity. It follows from the recognition that customers look for health and
nutrition in several product-categories other than biscuits |
Don't let their innocuousness lull you into thinking
that these changes are merely part of a routine repositioning initiated by an ageing
brand. The desire to launch a product for every segment of the market, intensify market
penetration, and diversify into foods is indicative of a revolution at Britannia: an
intention to look beyond the product at the customer. And every gambit in Alagh's
marketing game-plan can be traced to a new-found focus on the customer.
Brandishing Brands
As any company that has recently launched a brand of cheese
should know, two customers can be as different as chalk and cheese. Britannia's customers
range from the rural gamin, who spends a few rupees on a packet of Tiger at the local
paan-shop, to the health-conscious urban housewife, picking up a month's supply of Marie
Gold at a supermarket. Any company that wishes to cater to a customer-base as varied as
this needs to possess a large portfolio of brands. With different USPs, positioned at
different price-points, yet unified under a uniquely differentiated mother brand that is
near-generic: Britannia.
A biscuit is, well, a biscuit-made of wheat flour, sugar,
leavening agents, emulsifiers... How could Britannia make its biscuits any different? As a
starting-point, between late 1995 and early 1997, Britannia conducted qualitative and
quantitative research, surveying over 5,000 consumers, to find out how they perceived the
brand. One finding: the customer looks at Britannia as a trusted and a caring brand-one
that she grew up with. Such values were not unique to Britannia; brands like Johnson &
Johnson and Dabur enjoyed the same virtues in the customer's mind. Points out Sandeep
Puri, 35, Associate Director, Ammirati Puris Lintas, Britannia's ad agency: ''We had to
create a more tangible association. Health and nutrition came to mind when we discovered
that, across demographic segments, all our customers are health-conscious.''
The attribute rubbed off easily on biscuits. Since mothers
prefer baked products as a snacking option for their children, positioning Britannia
biscuits on the health platform didn't erode the brand's value; it enhanced it. It was a
repositioning that did not have any intrinsic boundaries either. Claims Puri: ''With the
health plank, Britannia could enter other markets too.'' After zeroing in on the
attribute, it was a short step for Alagh and his team to work out the precise positioning
of the mother brand: Eat Healthy, Think Better.

"We have
incorporated new segmentation tools as each brand cluster offers specific benefits.."
Vikram Kaushik
V-P (Mktg & Exports) Britannia |
Apart from re-positioning each one of its biscuits
brands on the new platform, Britannia also used combinations of price and appeal-the two
elements of consumer behaviour-to straddle every segment of the market, challenging all
levels of competition. In a sense, it is the Levers model in detergents that Britannia is
emulating. Like it, Britannia has addressed a wide range of price-points: from Re 1 for a
sachet of Tidbits to Rs 12 for a 10s pack of Good Day Pista Badam cookies to Rs 15 for 100
gm of Cheezlets.
Similarly, Britannia has straddled the spectrum of segments
with different product-benefits. Explains Vikram Kaushik, 47, Vice-President (Marketing
& Exports), Britannia: ''We have incorporated relatively new segmentation tools like
Age Cohort Analysis, moments of consumption et al. Broadly speaking, each brand cluster
offers specific benefits to the customer.'' All of which only reinforce the mother brand's
new platform too.
Positioning Perspectives
Remember the product-usage axiom: it isn't what she uses
that is important. It's when and where. To a company aiming to be a snack-foods and dairy
major, this meant that the customer could be expected to use any of its products in a
variety of contexts: meal-times, snack-times, even while cooking. And the usage could be
just about anywhere in the country: in a town with a population less than 1 lakh or a
metropolitan city with a population of 20 lakh. For Britannia, meeting these demands meant
creating products for every possible usage-occasion, and a distribution reach that made
the product available within arm's reach of desire.
UNDERSTAND
THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN TARGET SEGMENTS. AND CREATE SEGMENT-SPECIFIC STRATEGIES
Britannia has launched biscuits and snacks targeting different needs and segments. Each
product is backed by advertising that is uniquely focused on the concerned target
audience, children to price-conscious housewives |
Britannia's revamped biscuits range covers a variety of
benefits. At the low-end price-points targeting the mass market, Tiger Glucose (Rs 5 for a
100-gm pack) and Tiger Cashew Badam (Rs 6 for 75 gm) are positioned as healthforce
biscuits. Consumer research showed that good health is the overwhelming objective when
mothers choose snacking options for their children; it also revealed that mothers are
aspirational for their children. Adds Kaushik: ''So, the selling line for Britannia Tiger
was Jam Ke Khao, Kuch Ban Ke Dikhao (Eat Lots, Become Something). The proposition
repositioned our brands, and brought a contemporary feel to the advertising.''
That was necessary because this is a volumes segment, where
Britannia's presence was negligible. Earlier, Britannia had vacated it, leaving it to its
biggest adversary, Parle Products' Parle-G biscuits. Glucose biscuits account for half the
volumes of the organised sector, with the highest penetration-levels across categories. It
is also the fastest-growing, clocking a growth of 10 per cent per annum. Ten years ago,
Britannia had addressed this segment with Glucose D and Circus, but its attempt to focus
on 2 brands instead of one didn't take it anywhere.
Admits Alagh: ''We didn't pay much attention to glucose
biscuits because it was regional, and had low profits potential. Moreover, the strategy
used to counter Parle-G became a me-too approach. This has been corrected with Tiger.''
Indeed, the new brand has been a roaring success. Within a year of launch, Tiger Glucose
and Tiger Cashew have, together, achieved a turnover of Rs 100 crore and a marketshare of,
according to the company, 30 per cent in the glucose biscuits segment.
Next, Britannia focused on its core biscuit brands-like
Marie, Thin Arrowroot, and Milk Bikis-which were facing competition from similarly-branded
alternatives like Bakeman's English Marie, Milka Biscuits, and Priya Marie. To stay ahead
of the pack, Britannia differentiated its brands by not only bringing them under the Eat
Healthy, Think Better banner, but also gave them clearly-defined positionings. For Milk
Bikis, targeted at children, Britannia launched variants like Milk Bikis Funland, which
are animal-shaped biscuits. Marie was rechristened Marie Gold, and positioned as a
tea-time biscuit. And Thin Arrowroot was renamed Jacob's Thin, with its position as the
low-calorie health biscuit reinstated.
Finally, in January, 1999, Britannia relaunched another set
of its brands-Thinlite, Cream Cracker, and Digestive-under the Nutrichoice umbrella.
Targeting the fast-growing health-conscious segment, these biscuits were relaunched on a
low-calorie, high-nutrition platform. The repositioning, says Alagh, has strengthened
these brands, and broadened the range to cover several price-points and consumer segments.
For instance, Britannia has been quick in catching the
uptrend in impulse category snacks, like chips and chocolates. Recognising this trend,
Alagh targeted the under-24 urban consumer with trendier products like Little Hearts, Pure
Magic, and Chekkers, positioning them with statements they identify with: Direct Dil Se
for Little Hearts, Full Of Taste And Fun for Pure Magic, and For The Ups And Downs In Life
for Chekkers.
Recently, Britannia has even launched Snax, a line of ethnic
snackfoods in 3 variants: Calcutta Ka Chana Choor, Bikaner Ka Bhujiya, and Rajasthan Ka
Aloo Bhujiya. Healthy snackfoods? Well, yes, because these products are baked by
Britannia-not fried. Alagh claims that Britannia is using low-fat oils and hygienic
processes to reinforce the brand's core attribute in a category not typically associated
with health.
OPERATE
IN A FEW MARKETS. BUT, WITHIN THEM, TRY TO BE ALL THINGS TO ALL PEOPLE
Britannia has biscuits priced at Re 1 a pack; it also has biscuits priced at Rs 15 a pack.
The company has also expanded its retail network five-fold, with an emphasis on small
towns and rural markets, where the growth is taking place |
Britannia is gung-ho about its repositioned biscuit
brands. Gloats Alagh: ''It would not be out of place to mention that, in biscuits, Groupe
Danone is the world's No. 1 brand. And we are India's No. 1. While we would not like to
underplay the strengths of our competitors, it is also true that other than the British
biscuit-maker, United Biscuits, which owns the McVities' brand, the business is alien to
all the other new entrants.''
To boost volumes, Britannia has also revisited its packaging
strategy. Taking a leaf out of the book of the FMCG majors, Alagh launched biscuits in
small sachets last year. Low-priced sachets brought its biscuits, like Tiger
Tikis-nibblets priced at Re 1-to the mass market. Simultaneously, a revamping of its
distribution channels has taken place. Britannia has, over the last 4 years, increased its
retail distribution network from 250,000 to 1.20 million outlets. Between 60 and 70 per
cent of the new outlets are in the rural and semi-urban markets-a break with the past,
when Britannia's distribution was distinctly skewed towards urban India.
To increase its penetration, Britannia is now pushing a
bigger range of its products at each outlet. Using the low-priced Tiger brand as the
vehicle, what were previously urban brands, like Marie Gold and 50-50, are now travelling
down the population strata. In what it calls Operation Storming to boost rural growth,
Britannia has gone the HLL way by putting up wall-paintings, and participating in fairs
and festivals. Such efforts are paying off. In 1997-98, Britannia's volumes grew by 16.50
per cent-more than double the 7 per cent rate at which the industry grew. And Alagh says
he wants to clock 50 per cent higher growth than the market every year.
Beyond Biscuits
A customer who buys Benetton isn't really buying a T-shirt;
she's buying attitude. It didn't take long for the born-again Britannia to realise that
its customers weren't really buying biscuits; they were buying health, nutrition, and
food. The rest was easy. If it was nutrition-not biscuits-that the customer was buying
when she bought Britannia, why not extend the brand to other markets where the customer
looked for nutrition in every purchase?
While the bulk of Britannia's turnover comes from biscuits,
Alagh has food on his mind. Forty-five years ago, Britannia first diversified by launching
bread, marketing Premium Bake in a few cities. It wasn't unrelated. Like biscuits, bread
and cakes are bakery products, but their distribution logistics vary. Bread needs a daily
distribution system-unlike biscuits-and setting up such channels throughout the country is
tough. Local bakeries rule the roost, being able to manage the logistics of a smaller
geographical area.
True, big players like Britannia can forge alliances with
franchisees, but the margins in the business are slice-thin and, for a player with big
overheads, sharing them is not viable unless the volumes are huge. That's why Britannia
bread hasn't really taken off. Its presence is restricted to Delhi and Mumbai, where it is
just one of the average of 10 brands that sell in each city. But Alagh sees the business
as a base for his forays into other categories-like milk. Says he: ''The uniqueness of our
bread business is its daily-distribution system. In the future, it should be possible for
us to leverage this key strength.''
This has not deterred Britannia from thinking afresh. Says
Chairman Nusli Wadia, 54: ''It is our strategic decision to be a comprehensive foods and
beverages company, offering the consumer health and nutrition. We already are the leaders
in baked goods. In the last few years, we have launched dairy-products, like cheese,
dairy-whitener, flavoured milk, and butter too.'' It wasn't a coincidence that the
repositioning exercise came when Britannia was hatching an extension into dairy products.
Cheese and butter fit well with the health platform. Agrees
Rajat Sabharwal, 30, Research Analyst, Kotak Securities: ''The clubbing of the
repositioning exercise and the diversification into dairy-products has helped Britannia
accelerate its transition from being a biscuit-maker to a foods-marketer.'' That was
precisely the idea. Explains Alagh: ''A key reason for re-engineering the brand was not
only to make it more contemporary and robust, but also more stretchable.''
The big stretch took place when, in November, 1997, Britannia
debuted in the dairy products market with cheese. In just two years, it has grabbed a 35
per cent share. Market-leader Amul is way ahead with 60 per cent, but, for a newcomer,
Britannia has done well, overtaking older brands like Verka and Vijaya. However,
Britannia's swift success may have been due to skewed market dynamics.
Says R.S. Sodhi, 40, Assistant General Manager (Marketing),
GCMMF, the marketers of the Amul brand: ''Britannia found it easy because there was a gap
between demand and supply. Now that we have increased our capacities and, thus, supply, it
won't be a problem.'' Nevertheless, Britannia enjoys an edge: its distribution network
covers 5 lakh retail outlets through 1,400 distributors, giving it an extensive channel to
pump its products into the market. In contrast, Amul distributes through a wholesale
channel, where sales are, essentially, driven by consumer pull.
Cheese was followed by butter, and, now, Britannia has
launched flavoured milk, sub-branded Zip Sip, in tetrapaks. On the cards could be yoghurt
and other dairy products. Although Britannia's business plan could be bang on, volumes may
pose problems because it has targeted the top end of the market. Argues Rajeev Bakshi, 45,
CEO, Cadbury India: ''There is no problem with Britannia's plan. The issue is what part of
the business it wants to focus on. It has gone through the value-addition route, and will
now have to generate critical mass.''
That's why Alagh is exploring the possibility of entering the
milk market, where the margins may be low, but the volumes are high. Britannia wants to do
in dairy products what it has done in biscuits: cover all segments. ''As with other large
markets, we will seek to segment the market for dairy products too. This could mean that
our portfolio will include premium brands, with a high degree of value-addition, as well
as popular-priced brands that could add critical mass,'' says he.
The value-added dairy market that Britannia has targeted is a
minuscule 0.10 per cent of the market. While the size of the cheese market is a piffling
Rs 140 crore, it is growing at 20 per cent per annum. The Rs 400-crore butter market is
growing at 10 per cent a year, and Amul-the only national butter brand-has a 85 per cent
share. The Rs 350-crore dairy-whitener market is growing at 10 per cent a year, but large
brands like GCMMF's Amulya (marketshare: 45 per cent), Nestle's Everyday (32 per cent),
and HLL's Milkana (14 per cent) dominate it. To break into their domain, Britannia has
priced its brand, Britannia Dairy Whitener, 14 per cent cheaper than Everyday.
Success in dairy products will depend not just on gaining
marketshares. Explains Hozefa Topiwala, 27, an analyst with First Global India Research:
''These markets are small today. Britannia's success will depend on its ability to
accelerate their growth.'' Alagh takes a pragmatic view of the competition, where the
towering presence of Amul is daunting. ''The basis of our entry is the future size of the
market. Amul may be the largest player in the dairy market, but is not necessarily the
most profitable.''
Britannia's diversification isn't out-of-the-box; it reflects
its parent's portfolio. Ever since it got control of Britannia, Danone has been providing
it technology in biscuits and pastries. More important, its biggest business is dairy:
dairy products account for 44 per cent of its turnover, and biscuits, 20 per cent. Which
is driving Britannia's diversification. In contrast, dairy products account for a meagre
4.50 per cent of Britannia's turnover. But that is going to change. Reckons Alagh: ''In
the next 3 years, we expect new businesses (read: dairy products) to contribute about a
quarter of our turnover.''
Calibrating Costs
Britannia is in investment mode, spending on brand-building,
marketing, and promotions. Like most FMCG marketers, it manufactures only a small
proportion of its output. In biscuits, it outsources 65 per cent of its output from small
third-party contractors, who have inherent cost advantages. This also cuts distribution
costs as the suppliers are dispersed across the country.
Yet, Britannia's marketing costs are soaring. In 1996-97, it
spent Rs 29 crore on advertising, but, in 1997-98, when its foray into dairy products
gathered momentum, adspend shot up by 81 per cent to Rs 52.52 crore. Since the paybacks
from its new businesses are expected only 2-3 years down the line, what does it mean for
Britannia's bottomline? Fortuitous for Britannia are its healthy financials.
In 1998-99, the company's net profits, at Rs 39.60 crore,
grew a healthy 37 per cent while sales touched Rs 1,030 crore-up 21.50 per cent. The
biscuits business is the cash-cow that will fund its new businesses. Unlike other
transnationals, which remit large dividends to their parents, Britannia has been
conservative: in 1998-99, its payout ratio was 35 per cent. Plus, the company has managed
its treasury wisely, investing in government securities, mutual funds, and debt, and
keeping its cost of borrowed money at 5 per cent.
Britannia's risks are not financial. Instead, they are in the
marketplace. Alagh is confident about becoming a mass marketer in foods. Says Alagh: ''We
want to be a part of our consumer-at home, out of home-a natural part of his life. Consume
the product of your choice, but consume Britannia.'' That may not be easy.
Not only is the dairy business tough in terms of logistics,
the margins are low. Even a juggernaut like HLL is planning to hive off its dairy
portfolio. Says S. Raghunath, 43, Professor (Corporate Strategy & Business Policy),
IIM-B: ''How successfully Britannia is able to build cost and logistics efficiencies will
determine its ability to fight the competition. If it is not able to get its calculations
right, it will be tough. This is going to take some work on their part.''
Competition doesn't seem to faze Britannia's socialite CEO.
Nor does the size of his competitors. Declares Alagh: ''My personal commandment is, Do
Unto Others What You Don't Wish Done Unto You. It's not the big who swallow the small; its
the fast who swallow the slow.'' Since it has taken 8 decades for the company to learn
that lesson, Britannia will, hopefully, market better-and think faster-in future.
--additional reporting by Dilip Maitra
|