THIRD FRONT
Faultline soniaThe CPI(M) is thrilled
by the Congress' sucess but Laloo and Mulayam are worried about its revival in the Hindi
belt. A report on the Disunited Front.
By
Javed M Ansari
Clarity and unified action have never been the
strong points with the "third front". The term itself is among the more nebulous
entities in the confusing whirl that is Indian politics. Loosely, it is defined as a
conglomeration of every non-Congress, non-BJP grouping in the country. The communists and
the caste-based parties of Laloo Prasad Yadav and Mulayam Singh Yadav as well as the
Janata Dal (JD) are a constant presence. Beyond that, everything is negotiable.
The third front's reaction to the Congress' victory in the
recent assembly polls reflects its disparate nature.
- The CPI(M), led by General Secretary H.S. Surjeet is
ecstatic. It wants the Congress to quickly demolish the Atal Bihari Vajpayee regime.
- The Laloo-Mulayam Rashtriya Loktantrik Morcha (RLM) is
alarmed. It is worried about a possible Congress revival in Bihar and Uttar Pradesh.
- The Tamil Maanila Congress (TMC) sees it as yet another
reason to mend ties with the mother party.
- The DMK, the TMC's uneasy partner in Tamil Nadu, brushes
aside suggestions that the BJP-led Union Government must resign.
In sum, as the Indian polity moves inexorably towards
bipolarity the smaller parties are being forced to choose between anti-Congressism and
anti-BJPism. This should be clear to the third front which contested 350 of the 589
assembly seats in Delhi, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh, for which elections were held on
November 25, and won only 11.
The first indications of change have come from the RLM.
Mulayam, who was stressing a pro-Congress line till recently, has reverted to the shrill
ways of the past: "We regard the BJP and the Congress as two sides of the same coin.
From now on we will be equidistant from both." Mulayam has reason to worry. The
Congress' decisive triumph in Delhi and Madhya Pradesh could spill over to contiguous
Uttar Pradesh, his battleground. Since it lost power in 1990, the Congress has been a
non-entity in Uttar Pradesh. In the 1998 Lok Sabha elections it reached its nadir, winning
none of the state's 85 seats. Its position is scarcely better in Bihar, home to Laloo and
54 Lok Sabha seats.
Even so, in the November 25 polls, the Congress finished
second in the Agra assembly by-election. Mulayam's Samajwadi Party (SP) lost its deposit.
This indicates a possible Congress rebirth in the Hindi heartland. If this be so, Muslims
there may be willing to give the Congress another chance -- taking away one pillar of the
RLM's Muslim-Yadav edifice.
Ironically, the RLM may have contributed to this
rehabilitation of the Congress. Rues a senior JD leader: "The cardinal error that
Laloo and Mulayam made was that they gave a clean chit to the Congress. This prompted
Muslims in certain parts to do away with the interface and deal directly with them in some
states."
Now it is sinking in that the third force was at its
strongest as the United Front. Says Amar Singh, SP MP: "We must put aside our pride
and prejudices to revive the third force." Somnath Chatterjee, CPI(M) MP is
dismissive: "The Vajpayee government must go. We can't wait till eternity for the
formation of the third force."
A Congress revival poses no immediate threat to the
communists who rule West Bengal -- where the principal enemy, the Trinamool Congress, is
on the backfoot having lost two by-elections in the past month -- and Tripura and Kerala,
where no polls are due in the near future.
In the coming 15 months, a number of big states face
assembly elections. In Karnataka and Maharashtra, the Congress could do with the third
front's help in taking on the BJP. In Bihar, unless the Congress allies with Laloo, a
triangular contest may only help the BJP-Samata Party combine. So these elections will be
preceded by hectic bargaining: 1998 ended as the Congress' year; 1999, the Yadavs hope,
will be negotiated on the third front's terms.
Salaam Sonia
The Eight Month Slide The Parivar Hits Back |