It has to be one of the most misused words in the lexicon.
"Agenda" means things to be done, a programme of business for a meeting, a plan.
Every party -- or coalition -- has one. The pity is that it's usually their agenda, not
the country's, though they play blustery martyrs to perfection in their manifestos. It's
also why so much is left undone.
As the agenda is never one designed for change, when it happens there is little
conviction. The Congress had minimal plans for reform in 1991, for instance, the situation
forced the hand. "The only blueprint was the letter Manmohan Singh wrote to the IMF
saying it will do the following things," says S.P. Gupta, director and chief
executive of the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations. Harsh,
but true.
The two United Front governments that followed made flashy, forced statements about a
Common Minimum Programme. At least a decent joke has come out of the policy mess they have
left behind. "How could we get maximum results," wags a senior member of the
last cabinet, "when all we had in common is a minimum programme? We were bound to be
'Left behind'."
It shows. Substantially, little has moved. Today's long-overdue initiatives are the
same as those from two years ago. Such myopia. A wide range of moves like privatising
public-sector companies, making them more efficient, curbing government's administrative
expenditure, re-orienting bureaucrats, reducing subsidies and freeing private business
will not only help the government run itself better, but boost a hundred acutely essential
areas. Just one or two broad sweep moves like privatising the public sector and long-term
funds like insurance could provide enough money to pay for all the power, jobs and safe
drinking water that India needs in the next decade. There will also be enough left over
for better roads, effective defence capabilities, better education and sanitation -- a
staggering 600 million live without proper sanitation. "It's not just good
economics," says CII Director-General Tarun Das, "but good politics."
The government has to have the stomach to start the fire-fighting, and the heart to see
it through. Government has to stand firm when its bureaucrats start carping about losing
control, public-sector employees about losing jobs, party cadre about the inadvisability
of taxing rich farmers. These things have to be done. At best, it will pinch for a while
but it won't maim anyone except the inefficient. The country can't afford the luxury of
endless debate, but urgently needs immediate action. What follows are suggestions -- some
the government's own, unused research paid for with taxpayers' money -- about how India
can drag itself out of the muck.
So, welcome. But that's enough talk, already. It's time to get down to work.
GOVERNMENT
| Scale back ministries. Merge some, like Atomic
Energy, Space. Scrap some, like Civil Aviation and Tourism, Steel, Coal, Textiles. Create
Ministry of Infrastructure. Reform the IAS. Introduce specialisation so
that generalists don't run SEBI, RBI, airlines or defence.
Put IAS officers through mandatory schools like the army's Staff
College or National Defence College, in 10th and 15th year of service. Will ensure
training, specialisation.
Introduce Right to Information Act to monitor and stall corruption in
all Central, state and district-level public works, development programmes. |
The Government of India is like a decrepit old house. It requires too much money
for its upkeep, some portions are beyond repair and need to be demolished. And others
could do with some redesigning and modernisation.
For instance, there is absolutely no need to have ministries for Civil Aviation and
Tourism, Coal, Communications, Food Processing, Information and Broadcasting, Planning and
Programme Implementation, Steel, Surface Transport, Textiles, and Petroleum and Natural
Gas. Some of these, such as Civil Aviation, Surface Transport, Tourism and Communications
are better run by regulatory directorates headed by qualified technocrats, or, in the case
of Petroleum and Natural Gas, by autonomous corporations.
Equally, there is a case for merging some departments to form a single ministry like
Science and Development, and a Ministry of Natural Resources which will include
Environment and Forests, Water Resources, and Non-Conventional Energy. There's also a
crying need for a Ministry of Infrastructure that can oversee and track nationwide
development in a wide variety of areas, which autonomous agencies for road and highway
development, power, telecom and ports cannot do separately.
This re-orientation should be reinforced with the way the bureaucracy thinks, works and
earns. Accountability and efficiency must begin with the 5,000-strong IAS. If the Fifth
Pay Commission's recommendations on pay have been accepted, so must another
recommendation: elimination of 3.5 lakh vacant posts in government, plus 30 per cent cuts
in its overall size in the next 10 years. It would help if New Delhi stayed away from
handling state-level subjects like agriculture, education, health and so on. This will
build up state-level efficiency and make the IAS a leaner, more efficient machine.
-Manoj Joshi