India Today Editorials
Feb 14, 2000

METRO TODAY   |   DAILY NEWS   |   ASTROLOGY   |   ARCHIVES    |   INDIA TODAY    |  HOME


Cover Story | Nation | States | Columns | Newsnotes | From the Editor in Chief | EditorialsEyecatchers  Voices | Diplomacy | Cinema | Offtrack | Bodyline | Centrestage | Issue Contents


Take on the Mob

Safffron hooliganism is undermining Indian democracy

India Today issue dt February 14, 2000Those protesting against the making of Water in Varanasi are guaranteed their proverbial 15 minutes of fame -- or perhaps infamy. Unfortunately, they are also on the way to making a laughing stock of India. Deepa Mehta may be a good, bad or indifferent director but she has every right to exercise her creativity. Having obtained the necessary clearances -- re-obtained them, given her meeting with government officials in the past few days -- no cultural police has the right to disrupt her work. The inability to tolerate another view -- and the damaging of an M.F. Husain exhibition, the violence against a City of Joy or the banning of a Mee Nathuram Godse Boltoy are all manifestations of this -- is mobocracy, not democracy.

Take on the MobThe methods of the Sangh Parivar affiliates that are battling Water are, of course, objectionable. Their logic too is questionable. They want the film's script made public, seeking to judge intellectual property in the way the Inquisition decided who was a heretic. Their singling out of Mehta for an alleged defamation of India's most ancient extant city only reflects the complete lack of a sense of history, of the very tradition that is claimed to be defended. Two and a half millennia ago, Gautam Buddha made more critical remarks about Varanasi -- about its takeover by a self-serving priestly elite -- than Mehta would ever hope to. Presumably the Kashi Sanskriti Raksha Sangharsh Samiti will next run a posthumous campaign against that first great dissenter. From stopping cricket matches to film screenings, saffron vandalism holds all India to ransom. It is a painfully familiar routine -- first create a violent situation, then force the state to cancel the event citing a law and order problem. The mob gets what it wants -- forcing its opponents to compromise and earning itself enormous publicity. The only loser is Indian democracy, having to give that much more room to intolerance.


Stop the Gravy Train

Do cricket sponsors want to keep pampering mediocrity ?

Stop the Gravy TrainAbout a week has passed since the Indian cricket team returned home after the clobbering in Australia. The players are still omnipresent on the television screen -- smiling, giggling, gambolling, endorsing everything from toothpaste to suit lengths. For a bunch of losers, India's top cricketers certainly live a good life. They are unique in the sporting arena in that they are paid equally irrespective of performance. This simply should not continue. A system of performance-based wages offers scope for greater motivation. It will be argued that the cricket board's pay cheque accounts for only a small portion of a big star's wealth. Substantially greater sums come from sponsors. They are the ones who have a double duty to perform.

Corporate houses fund cricket in two ways -- officially through the board and privately by entering into deals with individual cricketers. It is time minimum standards of accountability were sought for these huge promotional budgets. Withdrawing from blindly pumping the board with money, let sponsors ask it for specific plans for developing the game -- and then finance these. When it comes to cricketers, companies should consider cutting their endorsement fees when they play poorly. This would make commercial sense too. Would consumers want to watch an advertisement featuring a batsman who can barely survive at the crease? Whether it is in negotiating with board officials or individual cricketers, sponsors operate in a seller's market -- if one company drops out, another steps in. Maybe the way out is for the giant sponsors to form a cartel and -- as the ESPN-Star Sports partnership did with telecast rights -- put the brakes on the gravy train. Otherwise, the game can chug along to damnation.


Indian music lovers click here

 

Top

Back | Next

 

ITGO

BUSINESS TODAY | INDIA TODAY PLUS | COMPUTERS TODAY
TEENS TODAY | MUSIC TODAY |
ART TODAY | NEWS TODAY | SYNDICATIONS TODAY

Write to us | Subscriptions | Advertise with us
© Living Media India Ltd