India Today Editorials
May 15, 2000

METRO TODAY   |   DAILY NEWS   |   ASTROLOGY   |   ARCHIVES    |   INDIA TODAY    |  HOME


Cover Story
Columns | Nation | Newsnotes | From the Editor in Chief | Editorials | Eyecatchers
  States | Voices | Behaviour | Economy | Neighbours | Profile | Offtrack | Bodyline | Centrestage 
  Issue Contents


Just Say No

India's decision not to send troops to Sri Lanka is eminently sensible

India Today issue dated May 15, 2000Alarming as the civil war in Sri Lanka may be, the Indian Government's unequivocal ruling out of any military intervention is most welcome. Diplomacy is that rare area where inaction is sometimes the best action -- and India's Lanka policy could benefit from a certain studied inertness. With the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) having vanquished the Sri Lankan Army in the northern JaffnaJust Say No peninsula, there were suggestions that the Indian Air Force would assist in the evacuation of Colombo's remaining forces in the region. As a corollary came speculation that President Chandrika Kumaratunga would invite the Indian Army to help keep her country intact. While the aspiration of a united Sri Lanka may be perfectly desirable, India is not the agency to achieve it. Crudely put, somebody else's war is not this country's problem.

It is a lesson India has learnt the hard way. In 1987, Rajiv Gandhi sent the Indian Peace-Keeping Force (IPKF) across the Palk Straits and triggered a series of events that eventually cost him his life -- and his country much goodwill. There was no clarity as to the IPKF's mandate. In the midst of its stay in Sri Lanka, it was suddenly told that the Tamils it was supposed to protect were actually the enemy -- but that the battle with the LTTE had to be fought with kid gloves. It was the sort of strategy that made the Charge of the Light Brigade seem a well-planned mission. It won India no friends, reducing its leverage in Sri Lanka to such an extent that today Delhi can only hope for the Tamil-Sinhalese conflict to be settled by negotiation but do nothing about it. Most tragically, Rajiv's blunder lost India soldiers who didn't even understand the cause they died for. The IPKF episode was one of the darkest in independent India's history. To repeat it would be a folly -- even if the alternative is to sit back and watch a stubborn regime slug it out with a crazed militia.


Hijacked Maharaja

The state is not the solution to Air-India. It is the problem.

In India, the P word is as much about privatisation as about patronage and parody. Take the debate over the sale of Air-India (A-I). The venerable civil aviation minister has proposed that no foreign partner be allowed to own more than 25 per cent of A-I's equity and in no circumstances should the Government hand over management control to a private company. The Hijacked Maharajaminister is by no means alone in his perception; across party lines many in the political class are in complete agreement with him. They share the belief that private and international airlines are just dying to buy into A-I, that India's "national carrier" is the ultimate prize the global aviation industry covets. Yet this is an airline that has continuously lost money since 1995-96, that is held to ransom by overpaid and utterly irresponsible pilots who happily expel bona fide passengers to take their family members on free trips. A-I is not a business enterprise, it is the economic equivalent of gangrene.

Aside from a handful, nobody in any position of authority in the Government is serious about selling off A-I. It is not surprising why. This summer -- as, indeed, every summer -- ministers and senior bureaucrats are busy trying to get their relatives and other cronies seats on A-I flights to the West. The international air travel sector is, after all, one of the last vestiges of the shortage economy. Flights between countries are governed by bilateral agreements. Since A-I -- expected loss in 2000-01: Rs 200 crore -- is incapable of increasing frequency, it prevents foreign airlines from doing so too. The ultimate loser is the ordinary passenger, not the freebie junkies who infest Lutyens' Delhi. The civil aviation minister's mindset is more suited to run the Bihar State Road Transport Corporation. Why is he wasting it on a global airline?

 
It's all about money, honey!

Indian music lovers, click here

 

Top

Back | Next

 

ITGO

BUSINESS TODAY | INDIA TODAY PLUS | COMPUTERS TODAY
TEENS TODAY | MUSIC TODAY |
ART TODAY | NEWS TODAY | SYNDICATIONS TODAY

Write to us | Subscriptions | Advertise with us
© Living Media India Ltd