September 25 Issue




COVER
  Growing Distrust
A surge in negligence suits, lax regulatory mechanisms and rampant commercialism seriously impair the credibility of the medical profession.

The Final Diagnosis



 
STATES
 

Swadeshi Time-Bomb
The Vajpayee Government's pro-market thrust is alienating the party's traditional support base and is causing disquiet in the ranks.

 
ECONOMY
 

On Fire Again
Global oil prices are flaring and a hike in diesel, LPG and kerosene prices is imminent. Here's why you will pay more than rising global prices warrant.

 
Columns
 

Fifth Column
by Tavleen Singh
Terrorised State

 
 

Kautilya
by Jairam Ramesh
Forty and Going Strong

 
  Economic Grafitti
by Kaushik Basu
Nietzche Century


 
 

Right Angle
by Swapan Dasgupta
They also serve India

 
 

Flipside
by Dilip Bobb
Sights Unseen

 
Other stories
  States  
  Nation  
  Business  
  Government  
  Sports  
  Cinema  
  Health  
  Cricket  
  Music  
  The Arts  
NewsNotes
 

Dot and Dotcom
For most ministers, it's "Sabeer who?" for the Hotmail man Sabeer Bhatia.

 
 

Forked Tongue
Buddhadeb Bhattacharya's tete-a-tete with S.S. Ray on a Calcutta bound flight from Delhi last week.
More...

 
 



 
  Home  
 

ECONOMIC GRAFITTI
Nietzsche Century

A death anniversary tribute to a troubled philosopher

By Kaushik Basu

August 25 passed uneventfully. There were notices here and there, in a British newspaper, in a German magazine. Yet 100 years ago on this very day, one of the greatest philosophers of the last millennium died. For a few years prior to his death he had become a celebrity. His books were selling in tens of thousands. His writings were being analysed, worshipped and vilified. The only person who did not know of his fame was Friedrich Nietzsche himself, because for the last 11 years of his life he had been bedridden, stricken with insanity and paralysis.

Since his death, the Nietzsche legend has continued to grow, and though his thought may not be the stuff of popular media, there has been an unbelievably large amount of writing on him, on his work and on his influence on the world of politics. The last is ironical, because he detested politicians, political parties and ideology. Nevertheless, a variety of politicians, many of them with completely contrary views, have claimed allegiance to his philosophy.

It is not difficult to fathom why this is so. Nietzsche did not write with the precision of an analytical philosopher. He had instead a rabble-rousing style, full of lyricism, and delightful in ambiguity.

What made Nietzsche so attractive as a philosopher was his passion. Plagued by migraine, poor health and spurts of insanity, living like a nomad in cheap apartments in European cities, he poured out his thoughts in books, pamphlets and letters. He wrote prodigiously, fearlessly trampling on conventional thought, almost as if he knew the end was near and so he had to put out in a hurry whatever he had to tell the world.

Nietzsche had many passions that failed him. He loved the music of Wagner and admired him, but eventually fell out with him. He was deeply attached to his sister since childhood but later grew distant because he had no sympathy for her and her husband's anti-semitism. He was very critical of the Germans' treatment of Jews; it is therefore ironical that the Nazis later claimed to draw inspiration from Nietzsche's philosophy. He was brought up in a religious family but came to denounce Christianity. Yet, he admired Jesus. "In truth," he once wrote, "there was only one Christian and he died on the cross."

Through all these ups and downs, one enduring influence on Nietzsche's thinking was Vedanta philosophy and the Upanishads. He had read these early in his life and his interest was reinforced through his admiration for Schopenhauer. Though he later outgrew this infatuation, he remained close to his schoolmate, Paul Deussen, one of the best known interpreters of Indian thought at that time. In many of Nietzsche's passages there are allusions to "maya". Thus he wrote about the world being "transitory, seductive, illusory".

Despite the power of his intellect, the insightful aphorisms that litter his work, his famous books, notably Beyond Good and Evil and Thus Spake Zarathustra, it is undeniable that his tragic life fuelled interest in Nietzsche.

Green Valley And The Appalling Snow: He was born on October 15, 1844. Four years later, his father became mentally ill and, a year later, died. He was brought up in a house consisting of a doting mother, a grandmother, two maiden aunts and his sister. In school and later on in college in Bonn he was recognised for his prodigious mental capacity. At the precocious age of 24 he was appointed professor of philology in Basel and three years later he had published his first book.

Everything seemed glorious and green. But all the while into his "green valley" was drifting "the apalling snow". He lived throughout in the fear that his father's mental illness would also afflict him. His father's ailment was perhaps not hereditary. Nietzsche's own mental illness was possibly due to syphilis, picked up during one of his two encounters with prostitutes. This was the greater pity because he had lived a near celibate life. When he did fall in love with Wagner's wife, Cosima, he could not get himself to admit this to her and almost not to himself. There is pathos in Nietzsche's entry in the asylum book, written in a state of delirium, that he was brought there by his "wife, Cosima Wagner".

Nietzsche became convinced that he would die in 1880 at the age of 36 just like his father. He retired from his work in 1879, citing poor health. When 1880 passed without event, he got a new lease of life and his classic, Zarathustra, was written in a last flash of enthusiasm.

The irreversible mental breakdown occurred on a cold January morning in 1889, when he collapsed on a street in Turin, clutching desperately on to the neck of a mare. Within days he lost his sanity completely and for 11 long years would be looked after by his mother and, after her death, by his sister, as he slid "gentle into the dark night".

(The author is professor of economics at Cornell University.)

Top

 
 
 
     METRO TODAY
  MetroScape  
   


Lord Of Colour
61 artists had an exhibition of Ganesha paintings, sculptures and metal relief works at the Vinyasa Art Gallery in Chennai.

more...

Looking Glass
Delhi: Hotel

Bangalore: Clothes

Chennai: Airlines

 
    Web Exclusives

COLUMN  



If the markets don’t recover in the next 48 hours expect the worst, says V Shankar Aiyar in Au Contraiyar.

 
DESPATCHES  


Targeting offensive and misleading commercials, vigilant viewers are now setting ethical bounds for the ad industry. INDIA TODAY Principal Correspondent Farah Baria looks at the new set of dos and don'ts in
Despatches.

 
EXTRAS

Full coverages
with columns, infographics, audio reports.

» 1971: The Untold Story
» Veerappan Strikes Again
» The Tiger Catastrophe
» The SriLankan crisis
» The Kashmir jigsaw
»The Nepal Gameplan

PREVIOUS ISSUE


Click here to view
the previous issue


 
.
CONTACT US SUBSCRIPTION PRIVACY POLICY