India Today Group Online
 


16 October 2000 Issue




COVER
  Operation Vajpayee
The prime minister's knee surgery will be the most watched medical event in Indian history. A Preview.

 
THE NATION
 

Bribe Gloom
The former PM's conviction snuffs out his plans to play a larger role in Congress affairs. But though the dissidents have lost a rallying point, they will go ahead with their anti-Sonia campaign.

 
DEFENCE
 

Big Buys
As India and Russia ink the biggest defence agreement since Independence, the Armed Forces hope to close the gaping holes in preparedness

 
Columns
 

Fifth Column
by Tavleen Singh
Poverty Of Ideas

 
 

Kautilya
by Jairam Ramesh
Rao Doesn't Deserve This

 
  Flipside
by Dilip Bobb
Body Language


 
  Politically Correct
by P. Chidambaram
Weighing Weakness


 
  Sportswatch
by Rohit Brijnath
Golden Games


 
 

Right Angle
by Swapan Dasgupta
It Takes Two To Coalition

 
Other stories
  Development  
  States  
  The Arts  
  Entertainment  
  Sports  
  Health  
  Cyberchatter  
  Diplomacy  
  Religion  
NewsNotes
 

Generation Gaffes

 
 

Existential Crisis

More...

 
 



 
  Home  
 

STATES: GUJARAT

The Rage of Friends

The BJP is routed in the civic polls in the state as hardliners avenge the party's abandoning of the Hindutva plank

By Uday Mahurkar

When an editor of a leading English newspaper met a senior leader of the Gujarat BJP in Ahmedabad last month, he was taken aback by the politician's arrogance. "We don't go after press publicity. We are so firmly ensconced in Gujarat that we don't need it," the leader boasted even as the editor pointed to the wisdom of keeping in touch with the media. Within a week, the world had turned upside down for the BJP as the results of the panchayat and civic elections in the state came in. The belief that Gujarat was a saffron stronghold was demolished.

Juiliant Congress leaders celebrate the windfall

The party lost in 22 of the 23 district panchayats and in three of the six municipal corporations, including in Chief Minister Keshubhai Patel's native Rajkot where it has consistently won since 1970. In a span of a few days the BJP's control over the civic bodies in the state came down from 90 per cent to less than 15 per cent.

The BJP's defeat is rooted in its decision to jettison Hindutva to suit coalition politics at the Centre. The strategy has cost the party dear in the state. Sangh Parivar affiliates like the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), which has a membership of almost two lakh in the state, felt betrayed by this volte face and kept away from the election campaign. Says VHP General Secretary Pravin Togadia: "The BJP was bound to pay the price for abandoning Hindutva."

Widening the chasm between the hardliners and the BJP was party President Bangaru Laxman's recent overtures to the Muslims. Increasing Gujarat's quota of Haj pilgrims and building a rest house at the Hajipir Dargah in Kutch at government expense further alienated the pro-Hindutva elements, so much so that many of them even voted against the party in the elections. As it turned out, playing the Muslim card did not work for the BJP. Although the party expected a good number of Muslim votes in these elections, the community seems to have voted entirely for the Congress party. As a senior BJP leader explained, "The voters have punished the party for replacing Hindutva with Muslim appeasement."

Double-Edged Sword: If it was a vote against non-Hindutva, it was in equal measure a vote against high-level corruption in the state. Finance Minister Vajubhai Vala, for instance, is facing charges of misusing his position to acquire huge properties in the city. Many now see him as the biggest real-estate tycoon in Gujarat. But Vala dismisses the accusations that he has bent rules to further his business. "How can I prevent these charges? My family has been in the real-estate business and will remain in it," he says without a hint of remorse.

Another reason for the party's debacle was the absence of Keshubhai's political foe and national BJP General Secretary Narendra Modi. One of the chief architects of the BJP's rise in Gujarat, Modi was banished from the state five years ago after Shankersinh Vaghela's famous rebellion. Modi's expertise in electoral politics and his organisational skills would have played a crucial role in reversing the situation. Says a party leader: "He would have identified the hostile signals from voters much in advance and taken corrective steps. The party wouldn't have been caught napping."

The panchayat and municipal results, however, are not a vote for the Congress as much as they are a vote against the BJP's mistakes. And nobody realises this better than Gujarat PCC President C.D. Patel. At a function organised to celebrate the unexpected victory, Patel handed out a caveat to party workers. "This victory has been given to us on a platter. So none amongst us should celebrate it with crackers. Instead we must strive to justify the faith people have reposed in us," he said.

Meanwhile, the chief minister has already set up a high-level committee for a post-mortem on the BJP's poll reversals. But few expect it to come up with any earth-shaking findings. That's because the committee is headed by Minister of State for Technical Education Bharat Barot, a Keshubhai loyalist and sworn rival of Modi. It seems the BJP is still not willing to learn from its mistakes.

Top

 
 
 
     METRO TODAY
  MetroScape  
   


Food Mood
There was plenty of food at the first anniversary bash of Crossroads mall and the shop-within-the-mall Good Food Gallerie in Mumbai last week.
more...

Looking Glass

Chennai: Exhibition


Bangalore: Electronics Store

Delhi: Gift Store

Delhi: Hotel

Calcutta: Sale

 
    Web Exclusives
COLUMNS  


By putting off rolling settlement, SEBI has given punters on Dalal Street a Diwali gift, says INDIA TODAY Associate Editor V. Shankar Aiyar in Au Contraiyar.

 
DESPATCHES  



The fate of the Kannur project in power-strapped Kerala is in a state of limbo as the Government contends it is too expensive. But is it? INDIA TODAY Principal Correspondent M.G. Radhakrishnan investigates in
Despatches.

 
XTRAS!

Full coverages
with columns, infographics, audio reports.

» 1971: The Untold Story
» Veerappan Strikes Again
» The Tiger Catastrophe
» The SriLankan crisis
» The Kashmir jigsaw
»The Nepal Gameplan

PREVIOUS ISSUE



Click here to view
the previous issue


 

India Today | The Newspaper Today | Aaj Tak | Business Today | Computers Today | India Today Plus | Teens Today | Music Today
Art Today | Jokes & Toons | India Today Book Club | TNT Astro | TNT Movies
Care Today | E-Greetings| TNT Forums | Archives | Syndications

Write to us | About Us | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer

© Living Media India Ltd