November 27, 2000 Issue




COVER
  The New Threat
Breast cancer is emerging as the most common form of cancer
among urban Indian women. But new treatments bring hope in an area of despair.


 
THE NATION
 

Victor's Cross
Re-election as party president was the least of Sonia's problems. She will have to balance coteries, and make difficult choices.


 
THE NATION
 

"It's like a re-birth"
Rajkumar is free, his fans are ecstatic but in the melee, the issue of Veerappan is forgotten.

 
Columns
 

Fifth Column
by Tavleen Singh
Comic Relief

 
    Kautilya
by Jairam Ramesh
High-Yielding Politicians


 
    Politically Correct
by P. Chidambaram
Private Notes


 
    Right Angle
by Swapan Dasgupta
Restoring the Balance


 
    FlipSide
by Dilip Bobb
The Coterie Watch

 
Other stories
  Business  
  Jharkhand  
  Punjab  
  Defence  
  Sports  
  Science  
  Diplomacy  
  Crime  
  Temples of Doom  
  Cyberwatch  
  Entertainment  
  Arts  
NewsNotes
 

Verse and Worse

 
 

Friends Forever

More...

 
   

Fight the Draught

 
 



 
  Home  
 

FIFTH COLUMN

Comic Relief

By trying to propagate its fossilised ideas the RSS is making a laughing stock of itself

By Tavleen Singh

For once the RSS offers us not just free advice but free entertainment. The BJP's favourite cultural organisation is currently sending its best and brightest workers to traverse the land in the hope of luring back good Hindu youths to those increasingly thinly attended shakhas. As part of this campaign, the RSS has armed its workers with literature that has been designed to teach Indians to be more Indian. This is understandable since westernised Indians tend to find the spectacle of men in khaki knickers doing martial exercises amusing rather than inspiring. So, the RSS thinks that if they can be persuaded to shed their western ways and become more swadeshi those dawn drills might have more appeal.

What offers immense entertainment, though, is the RSS idea of what being a good Indian is. Did you know, for instance, that if you think of a honeymoon as a pleasant way to spend your first few days of marriage then you would be considered a seriously bad Indian? The RSS has produced a Marital Code of Conduct that rules against honeymoons on the grounds that they could lead to the end of our proud joint family system. "A honeymoon encourages a couple to go for a vacation without the rest of the family ... (this) gives rise to the feeling that the rest of the family is an obstacle to individual freedom." In other words if you must take a vacation after you get married be sure to take along the entire family-two sets of mothers- and fathers-in-law, brothers, sisters, their wives, husbands and, perhaps even the family dog. It would not be much of a holiday-and certainly no honeymoon-but this, according to the RSS, is the Indian way.

Being a good Indian also means rejecting feminism as yet another western plot to destroy our Sati Savitris and-despite our population problems-being good Indians also means rejecting family planning. Mere "economic considerations" must not decide how many children you have and although it goes unsaid (except privately) we need to keep breeding Hindus to keep up with the Muslims.

These new ideas from the RSS think tank come from a desperate fear of westernisation. Everything foreign is bad-including, naturally, Muslims and Christians-so we must shun foreignness. But what about those khaki knickers? Are they part of ancient Indian couture? Surely, even if only to spare us the sight of middle-aged men prancing around in badly stitched shorts they should be replaced by dhotis. We have an abundance these days of indigenous designers so it should be quite easy to persuade Tarun Tahiliani or Rohit Bal to come up with a more Indian uniform. And what about all the other western accoutrements that the RSS affects-like mobile phones, fax machines and websites? Out with them too, along with toothpaste and television and the nuclear bomb. If western ideas about honeymoons and Valentine's Day are to be rejected then we need to be consistent and reject everything else as well.

Un-Indian Ideology: More seriously, though, what gives the RSS the gall to dictate to us the rules of being Indian when at its most fundamental level its own ideology is disturbingly un-Indian. Anybody with even a passing knowledge of Indian civilisation knows that religious tolerance is a basic tenet. We accept, unlike the Semitic religions, that people have the right to worship their own gods in whichever way they wish. But the RSS does not agree. It wants Muslims and Christians to join what it calls the "mainstream" and constantly advises them to change their ways.

Well, perhaps it is time that the RSS considered joining the mainstream itself. As things stand the RSS has a limited "mainstream" involvement. Its ranks are populated mainly by upper-caste Hindus, causing not only Muslims and Christians but even lower-caste Hindus to stay away. So which mainstream are we talking about?

Meanwhile, since the RSS loves dishing out free advice here is some for them. Please, please continue producing pamphlets explaining the RSS version of Indian life. It is important that ordinary Indians realise quickly that the India the RSS dreams of is a country in which every aspect of their lives-right down to their very thoughts and ideas-will be dictated by an organisation run by a bunch of old men with fossilised minds. Unluckily for the BJP, it is going to be the main victim of this propaganda exercise. Since it has shown itself to be completely incapable of cutting the umbilical cord that binds it to its alma mater it will have to suffer the consequences. How many Indians are going to vote for a political party which believes that not just honeymoons but feminism and family planning are bad things? Next time round who is going to vote for Atal Bihari Vajpayee when they know that behind him lurks the long shadow of Chief Bongabong (K.S. Sudarshan)?

Top

 
 
 
     METRO TODAY
  MetroScape  
   


MetroScape
Home Run
Stage specialists The Company Theatre has been making life a lot easier for sluggish Mumbaikars by bringing plays right to their sofa sides.
more...

Looking Glass

Mumbai: Music

Delhi: Art

Pune: Cafe

more...

 
    Web Exclusives
COLUMNS  



The Indian industry has increased its decibel level of whining. Instead, it should get the government to deliver, says INDIA TODAY Associate Editor V. Shankar Aiyar in Au ContrAiyar.

 
DESPATCHES  


A TV channel turns good Samaritan and helps trace missing NRIs in the Gulf. INDIA TODAY Principal Correspondent M.G. Radhakrishnan reports on its six-month successful run in
Despatches.

 
XTRAS!

Full coverages
with columns, infographics, audio reports.

» 1971: The Untold Story
» Veerappan Strikes Again
» Mission Impossible
» The SriLankan crisis
» The Kashmir jigsaw
»The Nepal Gameplan

PREVIOUS ISSUE



Click here to view
the previous issue

 
CONTACT US SUBSCRIPTION PRIVACY POLICY