December 11, 2000 Issue





COVER
  Invasion From the East
The sudden deluge of consumer products from China, Thailand, Singapore and Malaysia has opened up new shopping options for consumers.


 
THE NATION
 

Ministers Of Idle State
Appointed by the NDA Government with a view to appease groupings in a mammoth coalition, junior Ministers are only proving a financial drain.


 
THE NATION
 

Just Year Say
Ram Jethmalani finds few takers for his allegations that Chief Justice Anand is functioning beyond retirement age.

 
Columns
 

Fifth Column
by Tavleen Singh
Poverty Politics

 
    Kautilya
by Jairam Ramesh
Great Mall Of China


 
    Politically Correct
by P. Chidambaram
Make The Buck Stop


 
    Right Angle
by Swapan Dasgupta
At Peace With Angrezi
 
    FlipSide
by Dilip Bobb
Mixed Doubles
 
Other stories
  Indian Divorces Act  
  Kashmir Cease-Fire  
  Neighbours  
  Heritage  
  Cyberspace  
  Cricket  
  Music  
  Cinema  
  Economy  
NewsNotes
 

Dying Tone

 
 

Hedging His Bets
More...

 
 



 
  Home  
 

NEIGHBOURS: PAKISTAN

Civil Line Blues

A surge in resignations by civilian ministers, an emerging unity in political opposition and a sinking economy put Musharraf on shaky ground

By Rory McCarthy in Islamabad

At the beginning no one was surprised by the handful of civilians who resigned one after another from Pakistan's military Government. Now, more than a year after General Pervez Musharraf seized power, the growing list of top-level appointees who have quit is hard to ignore. Musharraf, always the supremely confident military man, never looks perturbed by the problems around him. But even the impeccably dressed general must now be wondering where he went wrong and what happened to the bold agenda for reform unveiled immediately after the coup in October 1999.

Unable to deliver, Mushrraf finds himself staring at an abyssa

Two more senior officials resigned from the Government this past week. Law minister Aziz Munshi stepped down, apparently to concentrate on his work as attorney-general, and Syed Raziuddin Rizvi, a senior Shia leader, resigned as adviser to Musharraf in protest against the poor police response to the murder of a top Shia figure last month. That brings to 16 the number of senior civilian appointees who have stepped down, among them ministers, provincial ministers and provincial governors.

They also include the outspoken corruption prosecutor, Farouk Adam Khan, who quit in mid-November. Khan said he was leaving after the general running the anti-corruption National Accountability Bureau (NAB) was replaced in a reshuffle. "This has been a task of gigantic proportions," Khan said. "I think we made our share of mistakes and when I approached this job I think I was naive. We are talking about a culture of corruption that is pervasive."

The flood of resignations has raised questions about the freedom given to civilian figures to operate under military rule. Retired and serving military figures now hold many of the senior positions in the country. Others who have left include information minister Javed Jabbar, who was asked to quit by Musharraf himself after failing to project a sufficiently positive image of the regime.

Typically unruffled, the general insisted the resignations meant nothing. "Whosoever will resign, I will accept it as nobody is indispensable," he said after Jabbar left. "Selection is on merit and continuation is on performance."

But there is little doubt that Musharraf has alienated many of the country's senior politicians who, for a year, secretly harboured hopes that they would be brought into government to give a civilian look to the military rule. And so last week, the Pakistan Muslim League (PML), which was unceremoniously forced out of office by the coup, has agreed to end its feuding with the Pakistan People's Party (PPP) and start working together to bring down the military regime.

The unlikely alliance represents the first major political challenge to the army rule and brings together supporters of Nawaz Sharif, who is in jail serving a life sentence for hijacking, and his life-long rival Benazir Bhutto, who moved to London after being convicted of corruption last year. Ironically the group is led by veteran kingmaker Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan, a man who has in the past led alliances against Bhutto with the support of Sharif and then alliances against Sharif with Bhutto's backing.

Some in the PML, including Ijaz-ul-Haq, son of General Zia-ul-Haq and a man tipped as a potential prime minister, are aghast at the deal. Last month, party members opposed to the alliance stormed into the PML's headquarters in Islamabad, ripped down portraits of Sharif from the wall and burnt them as hundreds of supporters cheered outside. Haq and other dissidents appear to hold out the hope of an accommodation with the military regime. But Musharraf appears unlikely to relinquish power to any politician for now.

Haq and three others are now close to being expelled from the party, signalling a deep rift in the traditionally pro-establishment PML. But the party mainstream insists that now is the time to stand against the military. "The politics of the country has taken a new turn and new rules of the game have been made," said Sabir Shah, a senior pro-Sharif party leader. Sharif's wife, Kulsoom, who has no official party post and rarely spoke out when her husband was in power, is in favour of the alliance and has most of the party on her side. "I will make it a national movement so that the entire political fraternity joins hands against the military rulers for the restoration of democracy," she said. However, in Musharraf's favour there has still been little obvious public support for the new alliance.

The political fracas comes just a month before the nationwide local elections, the first ballots since the coup. The new cross-party alliance said it opposes the elections because it believes they are designed to weaken Pakistan's political parties and will boycott them. Although the vote is supposed to be on a non-party basis there is, however, little doubt that every major political group will be using its influence to have its people elected.

"The PML, much more than other parties, needed to show unity in its ranks to pass the first practical test of political power since the military takeover last year," The News daily said in an editorial. "With its top leader rotting in jail and second-tier leadership broken in two, the Muslim League is in a sorry state."

Pg. 1

Top

 
 
 
     METRO TODAY
  MetroScape  
   


MetroScape
Signor Style
At a Benetton store in Delhi's Greater Kailash I market, the billionnaire Italian sportingly donned a bandhini turban for the benefit of the non-stop flashbulbs.
more...

Looking Glass

Delhi: Restaurants

Mumbai: Cafe

 
    Web Exclusives
COLUMNS  


Enron symbolises everything that's wrong with the way reforms were handled by M/s Rao & Manmohan, says INDIA TODAY Associate Editor
V. Shankar Aiyar in

Au ContrAiyar.

 
DESPATCHES  


That's what the Archeological Survey of India believes the hike in entry fee at key heritage sites will achieve. But the tourism industry is sceptical, writes INDIA TODAY Principal Correspondent Farah Baria in
Despatches.

 
XTRAS!

Full coverages
with columns, infographics, audio reports.

» 1971: The Untold Story
» Mission Veerappan!
» Mission Impossible
» The Sri Lankan Crisis
» The Kashmir Jigsaw
»The Nepal Gameplan

PREVIOUS ISSUE



Click here to view
the previous issue

 
CONTACT US SUBSCRIPTION PRIVACY POLICY