February 5, 2001 Issue




COVER
 

Bloated Babudam
More heads, less work-that's the state of the bureaucracy in India. A privileged lot with guaranteed rights, pay and perks, they cost the taxpayers Rs 75,000 crore a year.The work culture makes them surplus but hard to get rid of.

 
THE NATION
 

Taking the
Plunge

Congress President Sonia Gandhi shedding her inhibitions and taking a dip at the Mahakumbha in Allahabad and the Vishwa Hindu Parishad's Dharma Sansad at the same venue were both seen as political moves.


 
STATES
 

Starved of Future
With the state reeling under a severe drought and government measures providing little succour, the prospect of a famine looms large. The debilitating results are now showing up as a chain of catastrophes in this rain-fed region.

 

 
BUSINESS
 

Puppy Paradise Professionals have turned Ludhiana into the richest city.

 
Columns
 

Fifth Column
by Tavleen Singh
Let's Get Real

 

 
 

Kautilya
by Jairam Ramesh
Core To RBI,Sore To Others

 

 
 

Right Angle
by Swapan Dasgupta
Knee Dip In Hindu Votes

 
 

Flip Side
by Dilip Bobb
Panic Stations

 

 
Other stories
  Diplomacy  
  The Nation  
  Cinema  
  Viewpoint  
  Profile  
  Arts  
  Crime  
NewsNotes
 

Luck's Abode

 
 

Pen Friend

More...

 
 



 
  Home  
 

NATION: CONGRESS

Taking The Plunge

Pushed by her spin doctors Sonia finally does it-the dip at the Mahakumbha is clearly aimed at recovering the lost Hindu vote

By Lakshmi Iyer

Until January 22 afternoon, Congress leaders didn't believe their usually stiff party President Sonia Gandhi would actually take the plunge. That is a holy dip-more precisely ardha snan or half dip-in the Ganga during the Mahakumbha in Allahabad. A day earlier, the party had announced she would do aachman-ritually rinsing her mouth-to symbolically associate herself with the mega Hindu event.

ACT OF FAITH: Sonia with the Shankaracharya of Dwarka Peeth

As images of a Sonia knee-deep in water emerged, the Congress went catatonic. Its Italian-born Roman Catholic leader had shed her European inhibitions. It seemed she had ended the ambiguity about her faith on the banks of a river most sacred to Hindus. She performed a mini ritual for the dead, including brother-in-law Sanjay, befitting her status as a daughter-in-law of a Kashmiri Pandit household. She then went to receive the blessings of the party's very own Shankaracharya Swami Swaroopanand of Dwarka Peeth, an unrelenting foe of the BJP and VHP. At the Shankaracharya's camp, veteran leader N.D. Tewari spoke of Hindutva, and bhajans and kirtans were sung by monks during the wait for Sonia. "Gau mata ki jai. Gau hatya band karo," they chorused.

To Congressmen-in quest of a formula to win middle Hindu India's approval-Sonia's profession of faith in Hinduism could not have been better timed or better located. It was made a day after the VHP-backed Dharma Sansad at the same venue set a deadline for the Government to remove all hurdles in the path of a Ram temple in Ayodhya. That the party saw the dip as a piece of competitive mobilisation of Hindus wasn't left in doubt. The Mahakumbha cannot be a monopoly of the VHP, asserted spokesman Anand Sharma. Says veteran party leader V. Gadgil: "It is a bold and wise decision. It will halt the alienation of Hindus from the Congress." Sonia's Mahakumbha journey is in a way a triumph of his line. Last April he was dropped from the Congress Working Committee for suggesting the party rethink the basis of its secularism and socialism.

Spin doctors place the latest riverside ritual in the continuum of Sonia's efforts in the past two years to identify herself with Hindus. On January 12, 1999, she declared India was primarily secular because of Hinduism. Two days later the CWC passed a resolution endorsing her viewpoint. "The dip is aimed at drowning the propaganda against Sonia's foreign origins," says a senior party functionary. "It's a feel good factor for party workers. Abstract secularism and anti-Hindu stands don't work in rural areas." In a letter, Gadgil urged Sonia to crown her Mahakumbha dip with a reiteration of her January 1999 statement. "If pluralism is the source of secularism then Hinduism is nothing but pluralism. The party must emphasise it."

If the dip has put the caste Hindu leaders in the party on overdrive, it has created disquiet among Muslim leaders. They feel it could raise Muslim suspicions that the Congress was once again indulging in soft Hindutva the way it did in 1989 by performing a shilanyas at Ayodhya and when Rajiv Gandhi launched his election campaign from the town promising Ram Rajya. They also feel it would give a handle to rivals like the Samajwadi Party in Uttar Pradesh to wean away the community. "Muslims won't react on the basis of one action; they will look at the cumulative steps she will take," explains a Muslim leader. His worry is the leaders who are pushing for soft Hindutva may now push harder to take more steps to placate Hindus. "Next they will ask her to visit Somnath. Then we will find it difficult to explain things to our people," he points out.

On record Muslim leaders are stoic and project Sonia's dip as an act of faith. "I have been on the Haj. That doesn't make me anti-Hindu," says AICC General Secretary Mohsina Kidwai. Former UPCC president Salman Khurshid says, "Muslims have taken it in their stride. Sonia visited Ali Mia at Nadwa. Her Sangam trip is personal." Even M.L. Fotedar, the prime mover behind the dip clarifies, "Sonia's visit is in conformity with the tradition of the Nehru family. It has always responded to the impulses and beliefs of broad masses." He recalls both Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi visited the Kumbha when they were prime minister. "Allahabad is after all home to them."

The dip has certainly changed the mood at the party headquarters on 24 Akbar Road. Gone is the secular belligerence that marked the atmosphere during December's furore over Ayodhya. It is a season of redefinition of secularism there. Says party Secretary Mani Shankar Aiyar, a self-confessed "secular fundamentalist": "The Mahakumbha is a cultural event. How is it an anti-Muslim act? To be secular one doesn't have to be anti-Hindu." Maybe not. But who can deny that in rhetorical terms the post-Kumbha Congress is sounding more like another party it claims to oppose.

Top
 

 

 
 
Care Today
 
 METRO TODAY
  MetroScape  
   

Heads In Golf
It seems the golf course is a welcome change from the boardroom. On a foggy Saturday morning last week, 96 of India's top CEOs braved the cold and determinedly made their way to ITC Classic Golf Resort near Gurgaon. more...

Looking Glass

Bangalore:
Coffee Bar

Delhi: Music

Bangalore: Cultural Festival

 

 
    Web Exclusives
COLUMNS  
 


If planned well, the quake could be the Keynesian opportunity for Yashwant Sinha to trigger growth,
says India Today Associate Editor
V. Shankar Aiyar
in
Au ContrAiyar.

 
INTERVIEW  


This is just the beginning, V.K. Aatre, who is at the core of the LCA action, tells India Today Principal Correspondent Stephen David in an exclusive
Interview.

 

 
DESPATCHES  


Managing home and
a career was always tough but women in the metros can now choose from an increasing array of options to work flexible hours.
India Today's
Namita Bhandare takes a look at the part-time and flexi-time job market in
Despatches.

 

 

 

PREVIOUS ISSUE




Click here to view
the previous issue

 

 
CONTACT US SUBSCRIPTION PRIVACY POLICY