February 12, 2001 Issue


India Today, February 12

DEATHQUAKE
 


True Horror:
Hell On Earth

Rescue and Relief:
Picking up the Pieces

Gujarat Government:
Is Keshubhai
Up To It

First Person Account:
Dateline Fearscape

Quake-Resistant Building: Preventing Collapse

Insurance:
Leave It To God

Economic Impact:
What Goes Down...

Looking Back:
Latur: Still Shaken

Good Samaritans:
State-of-The-Heart

Care Today:
Rebuilding Gujarat: Hope For Survivors

 
 
OTHER STORIES
  Caplooks
 
  Voices  
  Offtrack: On The Ball  
  Eyecatchers  
       
 



 
  Home  
 

DEATHQUAKE; RESCUE AND RELIEF

Contd...

State administration didn't identify epicentre till 3 p.m. on January 26.

Take Ahmedabad. For nearly three days the Government struggled to bring in cranes and earthmovers. It was left to senior BJP leader Narendra Modi to suggest that the railways should be asked for assistance. Removing those trapped in the debris requires gas cutters. It took Chief Minister Keshubhai Patel 48 hours to appeal for gas cutters on Doordarshan.



PROBLEMS OF PLENTY: With a relief plane coming from even Pakistan (above), Gujarat had more foodstuff than necessary, though particular medicines were still needed (below)

One of the primary principles governing crisis management is to expedite information. Congress leader Irshad Patel points out, "The first initiative should be to open communication lines. This Government did exactly the opposite." Till four days after the quake the media was left to speculate on the number of buildings that had crashed/collapsed in Ahmedabad. Upper and middle-class residents of buildings with cracks and believed to be unsafe spent days in the open not knowing whom they should turn to for checking their homes. The Government also failed to transmit the progress report to restore normalcy and allowed a sense of despair to envelop the state.

Not only did the Government not communicate, it often miscommunicated. At a select briefing to mediapersons a day after the quake, Keshubhai revealed that he believed over "1.25 lakh people were still buried under the debris" but denied it the next day. Just as this storm was dying out he caused another by declaring that "tremors would rock Gujarat for 48 more hours and that people should stay away from unsafe buildings". Result: panic.

It took over three days for the Government to get its act together. By January 29 it had sent 235 jeeps, 34 ambulances, 280 medical teams, 60 water tankers, 36 heavy earthmovers, 15 cranes, 42 gensets and 230 gas cutters for rescue work in Kutch. Even this would not be enough.

Awakening to the enormity of the crisis, Keshubhai also deployed six ministers, the Speaker of the Assembly and 20 MLAs in Kutch with clear responsibilities. On day four of the quake, seven senior IAS officers, 10 IPS officers and 227 other officials were in place in Kutch district to coordinate relief and rescue work. The much-maligned Gujarat State Electricity Board pulled off a minor miracle when it laid a 165 km line from near Morvi to Bhuj to bring power to a region where every other piece of the grid had collapsed. It took 1,500 workers three days of non-stop work to make that happen.

Number Crunch
The army deployed 22,500 troops in Ahmedabad and Bhuj sectors.
22 hours after the earthquake, 1,000 phone lines were working in Bhuj.
From Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan came 1,00,000 blankets.
Bhilai despatched
5 wagonloads of cranes for rescue operations.

The Government, by day four, embarked on the relief part. S.J. Haider, collector of Gandhinagar, reveals that by the evening of January 31, they had despatched "just from the Gandhinagar relief camp, 248 tonnes of fuel wood, 500 tents, 76,000 biscuit packets, 90 metric tonnes of milk powder, 846 quintals of cereals, 11 lakh water pouches, 425 tonnes of sukdi, 2,240 pieces of kafan cloth, 12,000 blankets ... to Kutch in 231 trucks. Also despatched were 1,661 volunteers, including 100 government officials and 55 doctors."

The task was daunting. "It was like waging a war against a mighty enemy," says Atanu Chakravorty, one of the IAS officers overseeing relief work at Bhachau along with 20 officials from his department. There were complaints that relief material flown into Bhuj had not quite percolated into the adjoining villages. There was also the problem of an overflow. Haren Pandya, state minister of home, says, "The response of people has been overwhelming. We have a surfeit of some materials but 50,000 tents, blankets, particular medicines and gensets are still needed."

The tragedy, almost unprecedented in India's history of natural calamities, has not cowed down Gujarat. After the 1999 cyclone, for instance, much of coastal Orissa was a picture of despair. Not so Gujarat. An alternative NGO network got activated after the quake. For starters, the Sangh Parivar's reach throughout Gujarat is unmatched. The first volunteers in Ahmedabad and in Kutch were RSS and VHP workers who worked along with the army (which eventually deployed 22,500 troops), the RAF and members of the gallant fire brigade in rescuing the trapped.

In the absence of the official machinery in Kutch, it was the RSS-VHP brigade that helped rescue people, nurse the wounded and even carry bodies for the last rites. On January 29, the residents of Nanireldi, a Muslim-dominated village in Kutch virtually starving since the day of the quake were pleasantly surprised to see a batch of RSS and VHP workers land with foodgrain, clothes and medicines. Said Abha Ibrahimbhai: "I could never imagine that the RSS and VHP workers would come to our rescue."

By January 30, over 8,000 Parivar workers were deployed in Kutch district. The huge effort was spearheaded by the VHP's International Secretary-General Pravin Togadia. Using an initial Rs 3 lakh, Togadia started by placing orders for food and other relief material. "I aimed to raise Rs 50 lakh to buy material but in many cases people simply provided material worth thousands of rupees free of cost." Working alongside the Parivar are social organisations, including the Swaminarayan sect, corporates and other voluntary agencies. Missing are the multinational NGOs, which flooded Orissa after the 1999 supercyclone.

FRATERNITY FIRST: Homeless victims were ditched by politicians, not people

By January 30, a sense of purpose and urgency had finally caught on with the Government. It roughly knew the extent of the damage across Gujarat. According to its estimates, private property worth Rs 6,000 crore was destroyed, public property worth Rs 1,000 crore would have to be rebuilt, the loss of assets managed by utilities like power and water services was Rs 1,000 crore and loss to trade and industry (including premises and opportunity cost) was a massive Rs 2,000 crore in just five days.

In terms of providing a roof to those rendered homeless in Ahmedabad, the Government announced that nearly 3,000 flats available with it in Gandhinagar would be offered free of rent to affected families for a period of one year. It was also formulating in conjunction with corporate houses long-term rehabilitation plans for other affected areas, including Kutch. Reliance Industries is donating Rs 15 crore and has adopted the town of Anjar. Essar proposes to adopt Surendranagar. Others like L&T and some PSUs have similar plans.

But what is most striking is the community spirit of the Gujaratis-in the state, across the country and overseas. School children in Mumbai are busting piggy banks to donate money, housewives from upper and middle-class homes have collected at community kitchens to cook food, doctors are working round the clock and businessmen are busy networking to bring the requisite relief to the needy. Ahmedabad is already limping to normalcy. So are Rajkot, Surat and Jamnagar.

Now if only the slothful Government could march in tune with the dynamism of its own society.

Pg 1

Top

 
 

 

 
 
Care Today
 
 

 PHOTO GALLERY

 
  Deathquake  
   

The Pain And Horror
The cataclysmic quake on India's
52nd Republic Day served to highlight
the gaping holes in the nation's
disaster management ability. Caught in celebrations, it was five and a half hours before Delhi officials even met. See The Latest Pictures

 

 
    Web Exclusives
COLUMNS  
 


Downsizing is not about getting rid of lower division clerks but shrinking the cabinet and thus the government, says
V Shankar Aiyar

in
Au ContrAiyar

 

 
INTERVIEW  

This is just the beginning, V.K. Aatre, who is at the core of the LCA action, tells India Today Principal Correspondent Stephen David in an exclusive
Interview.

 

 
DESPATCHES  

A delay in the implementation of an eco-development project in Ranthambhore forces the World Bank to drastically cut aid. But the Rajasthan Government is yet to learn from its mistakes, writes India Today's Principal Correspondent Rohit Parihar in
Despatches.

 

 

PREVIOUS ISSUE


India Today, February 5

Click here to view
the previous issue

 

 

 

CONTACT US SUBSCRIPTION PRIVACY POLICY