February 12, 2001 Issue


India Today, February 12

DEATHQUAKE
 


True Horror:
Hell On Earth

Rescue and Relief:
Picking up the Pieces

Gujarat Government:
Is Keshubhai
Up To It

First Person Account:
Dateline Fearscape

Quake-Resistant Building: Preventing Collapse

Insurance:
Leave It To God

Economic Impact:
What Goes Down...

Looking Back:
Latur: Still Shaken

Good Samaritans:
State-of-The-Heart

Care Today:
Rebuilding Gujarat: Hope For Survivors

 
 
OTHER STORIES
  Caplooks
 
  Voices  
  Offtrack: On The Ball  
  Eyecatchers  
       
 



 
\
  Home  
 

DEATHQUAKE; INEFFICIENT STATE

Contd...

Wrong Signals

By his actions, Keshubhai sent all wrong signals to a people looking for inspiration and direction.

The flipside of this stress on loyalty to Keshubhai is that while the chief minister hogs the authority, he also attracts all the flak. In the public mind, the Government begins and ends with Keshubhai. All the shortcomings of the regime are pinned on him. Conversely, the achievements of the Government cannot be transformed into political capital because Keshubhai's image has taken a nosedive.

Nowhere is this more apparent that in the relief work after the earthquake. It is conceded by even their worst detractors that the RSS and the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) have been in the forefront of the non-official rescue and relief. This has led to an upsurge of goodwill for the Sangh Parivar. Yet, it hasn't resulted in the BJP reaping political dividends. "We are at the centre of the relief work," gloats VHP Secretary-General Praveen Togadia. His office in Ahmedabad is buzzing with volunteers and overflowing with relief material while the BJP office conveys an image of clinical detachment.

GOING ONE UP: Togadia's office was buzzing with activity, leading to an upsurge of goodwill for the Vishwa Hindu Parishad

"We have suffered due to our dilution of Hindutva," rationalises Home Minister Haren Pandya. But this explanation sidesteps the problem of Keshubhai's image turning into a liability. This was on show during the past year's municipal elections when the BJP seat tally fell from some 80 per cent to 20 per cent. The party even lost the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation, a body it controlled for 17 years. "It was not a pro-Congress vote; it was an anti-BJP vote," concedes Pandya.

After the drubbing, the state party constituted a Satya Sodhak Samiti headed by Keshubhai loyalist Bharat Barot. Its report in January identified Keshubhai's poor media projection as a factor behind his waning image. The argument is that the Government's achievements, like the 30,500 electricity poles installed in just 40 days after the 1998 cyclone and the 10,500 check dams built in two years, haven't been adequately sold. If that is the case, neither Keshubhai nor the state Government appear to have learnt lessons.

Official stonewalling and a reluctance to part with information marked the first five days after the earthquake. When Keshubhai finally came on TV to warn of possible after-shocks, his clumsy articulation triggered a panic. It was clear that he was sending all the wrong signals to a people looking for solace on the one hand and simultaneously searching for inspiration and direction on the other. With his zero communication skills and his sluggish demeanour, the mismatch between society and its political leader couldn't have been more stark.

Pg 1

Top

 
 

 

 
 
Care Today
 
 

 PHOTO GALLERY

 
  Deathquake  
   

The Pain And Horror
The cataclysmic quake on India's
52nd Republic Day served to highlight
the gaping holes in the nation's
disaster management ability. Caught in celebrations, it was five and a half hours before Delhi officials even met. See The Latest Pictures

 

 
    Web Exclusives
COLUMNS  
 


Downsizing is not about getting rid of lower division clerks but shrinking the cabinet and thus the government, says
V Shankar Aiyar

in
Au ContrAiyar

 

 
INTERVIEW  

This is just the beginning, V.K. Aatre, who is at the core of the LCA action, tells India Today Principal Correspondent Stephen David in an exclusive
Interview.

 

 
DESPATCHES  

A delay in the implementation of an eco-development project in Ranthambhore forces the World Bank to drastically cut aid. But the Rajasthan Government is yet to learn from its mistakes, writes India Today's Principal Correspondent Rohit Parihar in
Despatches.

 

 

PREVIOUS ISSUE


India Today, February 5

Click here to view
the previous issue

 

 

 

CONTACT US SUBSCRIPTION PRIVACY POLICY