February 26, 2001 Issue


India Today, February 26

HUMAN GENOME
   

The Truth About Ourselves
The human genome sequence has been completed and shows some surprising findings. Despite having one-third less genes than estimated, human beings are still very complex. With access to disease genes, medicine and diagnostics will be revolutionised. However, this will also raise ethical questions on cloning and genetic privacy.

 
STATES
   

Hope In Hell
Four weeks after the earthquake, Gujarat is still coming to terms with the devastation. True grit is emerging from the rubble but it will be some time before lives are rebuilt. INDIA TODAY's teams went out across these death zones, capturing stories which record this renewal.

Simmer Time

 

 
BUSINESS
   

Profitable Loss
36 With over 90,000 employees opting for the VRS scheme, PSU banks are set to get over their problem of overstaffing. But is it going to make banks more competitive in this age of automation? Besides, it is also going to cost more than Rs 7,500 crore and will deprive the banks of skilled workers.

Paper Money

 

 
NEIGHBOURS
   

Spreading Terror
The attacks on Delhi's Red Fort,
the Srinagar airport and the city's police control room show the Lashkar-e-Toiba is increasingly catching the Indian security forces unawares-and emerging as the most daring terrorist group from Pakistan.

 

 
SPORTS
 

Face Off
It's David Vs Goliath as India play an Australian demolition squad at home. What makes the Aussies tick and how can India take them on?

Cricketwatch:
Ashley Mallett

 

 
CARE TODAY
  Mending Lives
The medical team sponsored by care today injected hope in quake- ravaged Gujarat-performing surgeries and tackling ailments.

 
OTHER STORIES
    Fifth Column:
Tavleen Singh
 
    Kautilya:
Jairam Ramesh
 
     
    Books  
    Music  
    The Arts: Jatin Das  
    Caplooks  
    Voices  
    Tremors  
    Confessional  
    Eyecatchers  
 



 
  Home  
 

COVER STORY: ESSAY

Romance of the Chromosome

After Moses and Marx, the molecular biologist

By S. Prasannarajan

Life Will Never Be
The Same
Origins:
Is This The End Of Racism
Medicine:
Can We cure All diseases
Ethics:
Can man Play God Now
Lab Talk
The Making Of Magic Bullets

On the sixth day of creation, the first scientist said, " Let us make man in our image, after our likeness; and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the birds of the heavens, and over the cattle, and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth." And He the Biblical God "created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them..." Mission accomplished, after closing the cosmic laboratory, he had gone to rest. Zillions of days later, man has taken on the Father, and from his terrestrial laboratory, unravelled the enigma of creation and unleashed the vision of a brave, brash, new world-perfect, happy, and genetically manipulative. He has reduced the distance between the cosmos and the chromosome.

A four-letter word has become the first word of a salvation text that promises the ultimate utopia, as beguiling as Eden, as ambitious as the promised land of ideology. So we are in the fourth stage of the evolutionary saga of Man the Magnificent: in the beginning was God, then God's kingdom on earth as envisioned by religion, then Good Earth as scripted by revolution, and now the immaculate liberation as authored by science. Each was a repudiation of the other, only the methods varied-and the promise was always the same: a world without warts, inhabited by perfect citizens, their perfection programmed by a superior authority. What's in religion, after all, especially in Christianity? His kingdom will come ... justice for everyone ... a classless, raceless society of equality, fraternity, and of course, love. Man is in need of permanent modification.

The New Man was the modified version, modified by the post-Moses architect of promise: Marx. Communism was Christ without the cross, salvation without martyrdom. It was not without reason that the novelist called the communist the engineer of human souls, a description more apt for God. But the communist was as ambitious as God; rather, he was the challenger with the blueprint of an alternative universe. As a fictional comrade argues, "The church has held man in doleful contempt. He is a fallen creature, doomed to sweat out his life sentence. Dust to dust. Marxism has taken him to be almost boundless in his capacities, limitless in his horizons, in the leaps of his spirit. A reacher to the stars. Not mired in original sin, but himself original." The all-encompassing scientific Weltanschauung of Marxism, the Service of Man was a rejoinder to the Worship of God: Eden on Earth is possible without the sacred scripture, the New Man of the Great Tomorrow can be created in the laboratory of socialism. Though, the liberation theology of the second Jehovah-bearded and German-has succeeded only in creating the Dead Man, still lying beneath the detritus of twentieth century's biggest hoax.

Now, we are in thrall of the fourth stage: life as an intercellular thriller, authored by the geometrician of genomes. After Moses and Marx, the molecular biologist. His utopia is as seductive as his predecessors'. It's Huxley redux, and this time not as science fantasy. As definitive - and defining - as your genes. Remember his Brave New World, published in 1932, set in the distant future, in the "year of stability", A. F. 632, i.e. 632 years after the advent of Henry Ford, with its Hatchery and Conditioning Centre and Alpha-plus mandarins and Epsilon-minus morons? That genetic utopia is here and now, and from the post-modern centres of hatchery and conditioning, dictators of our genetic destiny are promising us-not so distant from a fly or a worm or a mouse (what control, God, does man have over every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth and every flying thing that flies over the earth?) - eternal happiness, even immortality and reincarnation.

The same utopia, but different architecture. At the end (?) of the chase for the so-called Holy Grail of human biology, the "code of codes", the possessors of the genome secrets are in no mood to tolerate dissent, a trait they seem to share with the earlier utopians. Bioethicists may say it's the vulgarity of science, but the engineers of our cells will call it "another chance, man"-and it's the ultimate genetic bliss, cloning, the cellular equivalent of reincarnation. Already, the religion of biotechnology has got its own cult in the Raelians, the metaphysicians of genes who believe that humans were created in a lab by aliens from a superior civilisation. So who says you are one of your kind, singular and exceptional, irreplaceable? The end of uniqueness and the beginning of genetic socialism? Cells have no class, they may say, but can you rule out a genetic underclass if capitalism and chromosomes conspire to create Genome Inc? The end of suffering, they say, but isn't it a scientific variation of I'll-make-you-happy arrogance of the erstwhile revolutionary?

In the revolution of the microbiologist, too, the romance of chromosomes camouflages the fallacies of eternal bliss.

 

 

 
 
 
Care Today
     METRO TODAY
 
   

MetroScape
Delhi On My Mind...
I'm very flattered to have this act of 'piracy' take place," laughs William Dalrymple, as extracts from his engrossing travelogue City of Djinns: A Year in Delhi were interpreted by photographer Agnes Montanari and art historian Nathalie Trouveroy in an exhibition.
more...

Looking Glass

Delhi: Restaurant

Delhi: Exhibition

Mumbai: Exhibition

 

 
    Web Exclusives
DESPATCHES
  Re-emergence of rivers, sweet water springs' there has been much geological speculation after the earthquake in the Rann of Kutch. INDIA TODAY'S Special Correspondent
Uday Mahurkar
weighs the possibilities and concludes it's early
days yet in
Despatches.

 

 
 
INTERVIEWS
 

"I was very much against the idea of India," says William Dalrymple, author, The City of Djinns: A Year in Delhi. In conversation with INDIA TODAY's Sonia Faleiro, he talks about his old girlfriend, Delhi and his "enormously exciting" next book, The White Moghuls in Interviews.

 

 

 

PREVIOUS ISSUE


India Today, February 19, 2001

Click here to view
the previous issue

 

 

 

CONTACT US SUBSCRIPTION PRIVACY POLICY