| |
ENVIRONMENT: CNG
Unnatural Alliance
The Delhi Government and Nugas Technologies battle
allegations of a CNG conversion kit deal
By Sayantan Chakravarty
|

|

|
|
GAS CASH: A CNG
cylinder hoard (left); Handa (right) is at the centre of a controversy
|
For much of last
week, there was one three-letter word that dominated most discussions
in Delhi's official circles-CNG (compressed natural gas). It continues
to cause plenty of heartburn to bus and autorickshaw drivers and commuters
alike. At the centre of the controversy is Nugas Technologies,
the only company authorised by the Sheila Dikshit-led Congress Government
in Delhi to refit the Capital's diesel buses with
CNG kits.
Nugas is owned by businessman Ramesh Handa, who
makes no secret of his friendship with the Gandhi family. Last week, transporters
in Delhi were up in arms against him, and, on April 10, the first fir
alleging a case of cheating and detailing his role in the CNG kit scam,
was lodged at a Delhi police station. The Opposition BJP leaders also
joined the fray: Lok Sabha member Madan Lal Khurana alleged a collusion
between the Delhi Government and Nugas. At a press conference, he accused
the Delhi Government of promoting the "business interest of Nugas"
and demanded a CBI inquiry into what he termed a "Rs
200 crore CNG kit scam".
|

|
|
"RFAT
is no more than a roadside firm and its charges of a scam are baseless."
Parvez Hashmi, Transport Minister, Delhi
|
Suspicions of a deal between the Delhi government
and Nugas have been floating around for a while. Last November, the
CBI registered a preliminary enquiry with the Central Vigilance Commission,
following a complaint by a rival firm Rare Fuel and Automobile Technologies
Private Ltd (RFAT). The company has subsequently moved the Supreme Court.
The controversy dates back to March, 1999, when
the Delhi Transport Corporation (DTC) invited bids for the conversion
of its fleet of about 1,800 diesel buses to CNG, following a Supreme Court
directive in July 1998 in an air pollution case. RFAT acquired the pilot
project for the conversion of two buses with its third generation (distributor-less
ignition system) technology. RFAT says its conversion test results, carried
out by the Dehradun-based Indian Institute of Petroleum (IIP), were encouraging:
they showed a significant drop in pollution levels of hydrocarbons, nitrogen
oxides and carbon monoxide after the use of CNG kits.
"This is where," alleges RFAT's managing
director Sheetal Singh, "the scam began to take root." After
the trials were completed, Singh claims he was approached by former Janata
Dal MP Santosh Bhartiya, who promised him that the Delhi Government would
place a conversion order for 100 buses with RFAT provided he coughed up
a commission of Rs 1 lakh per bus for officials and politicians. Singh
refused and claims he is now paying the price for saying no.
Subsequently, says Singh, the IIP refused to
issue him a certificate clearing his CNG kit. In an affidavit filed in
the Supreme Court, RFAT representatives claim they were sidelined only
because the company refused to cough up the
Rs 1 lakh per bus conversion fee. Delhi's Transport
Minister Parvez Hashmi, who oversees DTC and is named in the affidavit,
dismisses the charges, calling RFAT a "roadside company".
There is, however, evidence to prove that things
may not have been all above board. On February 25, 2000, four days before
Nugas was actually incorporated in the records of the Registrar of Companies,
the Delhi Government placed an order for conversion with it. At the time
the company did not have a background in such technology and hadn't even
submitted a proposal for the order.
Handa is charged with using his connections
in the Congress to influence the Delhi government. Not only did he get
the order from the government-owned DTC, but nearly 5,000 CNG kits have
also been booked with Nugas by private operators. The price: nearly Rs
5 lakh per kit. And with about 10,000 of Delhi's buses awaiting conversion,
Nugas, as the city's sole supplier, stands to do business worth about
Rs 500 crore.
|
|