India Today Group Online
 


April 23, 2001
Issue


India Today, April 16, 2001

 

COVER
   

Say Hello to Another
Scam
The raging corporate war over the introduction of limited mobility telephone services has turned political, with the Prime Minister's Office being charged with subverting the regulatory system and favouring a few business houses. An INDIA TODAY investigation looks at the conflict between the sanctimonious claims and the grim reality.

 

 
STATES
   

Ballot Boxwallahs
The approaching assembly elections have brought to life five states which are set to witness a stiff fight and whose results can have a big impact on all major parties. A profile of the prime contenders who could tilt the balance either way.

 

 
BUSINESS
   

Fall From Grace
Despite a triple-digit growth in net profits of Infosys Technologies and Satyam Computers, the stock prices of the two companies have plunged. Is it the gloomy forecast for software companies that's hammering down the prices?

 

 
ENVIRONMENT
 

Unnatural Alliance
The CNG controversy has taken a new turn, with doubts being raised about the propriety of the Delhi Government's selection of Nugas as the sole supplier of the conversion kit.

 

 
EDUCATION
 

The Doon Boom
The city that houses Doon School is now playing host to a whole array of new education barons--with big money and even bigger ambitions.

 

 
OTHER STORIES
     
 



 
  Home  
 

ENVIRONMENT: CNG

Hashmi's Intentions 'Mala Fide'

Equally suspicious is how Nugas managed to convince the Delhi Government to order CNG kits at that price. When the government floated a tender in July 1999, it received offers as low as Rs 1,65,000-2,48,000 per kit. Among those who participated was RFAT. But the tender was called off by Hashmi on the grounds that none of the participants had met all the tender requirements. "We were awarded the first tender in March on the strength of our technology. So how could we be written off in July? Obviously, Hashmi's intentions were malafide," rails Singh. It is also from the prices quoted for first generation kits in this tender that Khurana estimates the dimensions of the scam. As a former transport minister in Delhi he alleges that the Nugas kits, at close to Rs 5 lakh for private operators, are double the rate of what they should have been. This raises the stakes of the scam to around Rs 200 crore-an amount Khurana claims will get siphoned away into private kitties.

Nugas suddenly appears to have hit a rough patch and now even its technology is being questioned. On April 10, hundreds of private operators were shocked when the Ministry of Surface Transport informed them that the certificate issued to Nugas' CNG kit by the IIP "is based on the emission norms of 1992 and, therefore, usable in buses manufactured up to March 1996" but "the certificate is invalid for vehicles manufactured after March 1996".

Poisoned Project

March 5, 1999: DTC floats tender. RFAT bags pilot project to convert two diesel buses with third generation kits.

July 23, 1999: DTC floats another tender. Gets quotation for first generation kits ranging from Rs 1.65 lakh to Rs 2.48 lakh. Tender not awarded.

July 17, 1999: RFAT test successful.

Feb 25, 2000: DTC ties up with new entrant Nugas, which has no experience in field. Nugas also gets clearance from Indian Institute of Petroleum.

Nov 10, 2000: CVC forwards complaint against Nugas to CBI which registers a preliminary enquiry.

April 10, 2001: IIP issues letter to Ministry of Surface Transport saying certificate issued to Nugas is not valid for post 1996 buses.

April 10, 2001: Ministry of Surface Transport issues letters to Delhi operators saying Nugas kits cannot be used for converting vehicles manufactured after 1996.

April 10, 2001: A Delhi transporter files an fir in a Delhi police station against Nugas, charging it with cheating. In his complaint, Himmat Singh says Nugas knew it was not allowed to convert his bus manufactured in the year 2000, yet took
Rs 10,000 for the CNG kit.

So if Nugas knew it could not convert buses manufactured after 1996, why did it take registration amounts for the kits from private operators? In the fir lodged by Himmat Singh, general secretary of the DTC Private Operators Welfare Association, it is mentioned that "this fact was never brought to my notice by Ramesh Handa and his agents ... Handa, knowing fully well that he was not in a position to convert my bus (year 2000 model), deliberately induced me to part with the Rs 10,000 booking amount".

What made matters worse for Nugas was a letter issued by the IIP to the Ministry of Surface Transport. Also dated April 10, it confirmed that the certificate issued by it was invalid for "all the vehicles manufactured after March 1996" as far as conversion was concerned. RFAT now says that it was offering third generation technology and yet the Delhi government opted for Nugas with its first generation technology for converting diesel buses into CNG ones.

All this has come as a huge blow to Nugas which is now threatening to sue the IIP. Nugas' spokesperson Yash Pal Arora says that there was a collective effort by some people in defaming the reputation of the firm as well as spreading rumours about the validity of its certificate. Nugas also claims to be in the possession of a certificate it received from an Ahmadnagar-based organisation on January 1, 2001, that permits it to sell its CNG kits to all transporters without validity problems.

These conflicting claims indicate that the CBI may be forced to initiate a probe. Until the many discomforting questions that have arisen are answered, the CNG controversy promises to spiral into a political and business storm.


 
 
 
Care Today
     METRO TODAY
 
   

MetroScape

Wealth Of Art
April 8 saw an unabashed get together of Mumbai's Who's Who when the annual Harmony Show, well known as "Tina Ambani's baby", celebrated its sixth showing at the Nehru Centre.
more...

Looking Glass

Bangalore Hotel:
Park.hotel

Mumbai Store:
Regent Watch and Jewellery Boutique

 

 
    Web Exclusives
DESPATCHES
 

A war of words is on at the Jammu border where India is trying to build a fence to stop infiltration, much to Pakistan's dislike, reports
INDIA TODAY's Special Correspondent Ramesh Vinayak in
Despatches.

 

 
PREVIOUS ISSUE




Click here to view
the previous issue

 

 

 


India Today | The Newspaper Today | Aaj Tak | Business Today | Computers Today | India Today Plus | Teens Today | Music Today
Art Today | Jokes & Toons | India Today Book Club | TNT Astro | TNT Movies
Care Today | E-Greetings| TNT Forums | Archives | Syndications

Write to us | About Us | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer

© Living Media India Ltd