| |
SPORTS: AFRO-ASIAN GAMES
Playing A Pricey Game
After 18 years of debate a costly, controversial
sports meet is cleared. Nobody knows why.
By Sharda Ugra
|
|

|
|
|
WORN OUT: Bharati inspects the battered track at Delhi's Nehru
Stadium
|
It is the simplest
of questions: does Indian sport need a nine-day sports extravaganza which
will cost the Government, the taxpayers and corporates close to Rs 80
crore? The Afro-Asian Games scheduled to be held in Delhi from November
3 to 11 have taken 18 years to come to fruition. Only time will decide
whether the fruit will be sweet or rotten but at the moment, most bets
are on rotten. Given government sanction in 2000, the Afro-Asian Games
will be the first-ever inter-continental sporting festival to be held
across eight disciplines featuring the top four athletes/teams from Asia
and Africa, with one Asian berth set aside for India. The Indian Olympic
Association (IOA) promises 96 countries, 2,500 athletes and a blaze of
goodwill and camaraderie. Former International Olympic Committee vice-president
and respected sports administrator Ashwini Kumar cuts through the hoopla
saying, "I am all for international competitions but this Afro-Asian
Games is part of a tamasha ... the money could have been better spent."
There are several factors at work around the staging of this sporting
festival, but few work in its favour.
|
"The
main benefit from these Afro-Asian Games will be renovated
stadia. The rest is friendship."
Suresh Kalmadi, President, IOA |
|
The Politics
The Afro-Asian Games hit the spotlight
when Sports Minister Uma Bharati postponed them last week saying she could
organise the games "but not its organising committee." Congress
MP and IOA President Suresh Kalmadi and BJP MP and IOA Vice-President
V.K. Malhotra were said to be jousting for the position of Organising
Committee chairman. The Congress-BJP sports dust-up goes back almost two
decades to when Malhotra was thrown out of the organising committee of
the 1982 Asian Games by then prime minister Indira Gandhi. This time he
probably thought things would go differently. The decision to postpone
the games was taken with the consent of Prime Minister A.B. Vajpayee.
However, Vajpayee changed his mind citing the importance of keeping an
"international commitment" to Bharati's embarrassment. His change
of heart has come about, it is said, due to Kalmadi's close relations
with members of the Prime Minister's Office. Malhotra stepped down from
the organising committee citing a packed schedule, "These are not
the Asian or the Commonwealth Games but will need 30 hour-days."
Bharati was appointed head of the organising committee with Kalmadi acting
as "working chairman."
|
THE PRICE WE PAY
|
|
|
# Accommodation and boarding for international
athletes and officials in five-star hotels are estimated to cost
Rs 20.32 crore.
# The expenses of the opening and closing
ceremonies, including the torch relay, are budgeted at a staggering
Rs 3 crore.
# The IOA has also set aside a sum of
Rs 2.40 lakh for the transportation of the torch relay committee.
|
|
The Economics
The organisers will pay for air-fare,
five-star hotel stay and allowances for athletes and officials. According
to estimates for the games available with INDIA TODAY, the accommodation
and boarding will cost Rs 20.3 crore. Other items budgeted for include
Rs 20 lakh for hospitality in VIP lounges and Rs 50 lakh slotted under
a sinister "miscellaneous". Of the Rs 56 crore budgeted for
by the IOA, the Government will pay Rs 20 crore and Rs10 crore is expected
from Doordarshan for television rights.
These costs do not include expenses for updating
infrastructure, relaying stadium surfaces and buying new equipment which
according to Bharati, should touch Rs 30 crore. There are no guarantees,
however, that the job will be well done as time is short. A Sports Authority
of India official says, "The National Stadium's base is potholed
and needs to be re-done before the hockey turf can be laid. But there's
no time and they are bound to do a shoddy job." The upgradation of
sporting infrastructure is the only benefit the games could bring. Says
Kalmadi: "This should be the start of a movement-once we have spent
on infrastructure, more international events will come to India."
Experience shows otherwise. The Amateur Athletics Federation of India
(headed by Kalmadi himself) has held only one international event in the
past four years at the Nehru Stadium after the track was relaid in 1996
for the Asian Junior Track and Field meet. The crores that will be spent
for these Games could change athletes' lives. Because of the lack of artificial
surfaces, hockey is still played on grass, athletes still run on mud and
cinder tracks and throwers can't afford the international standard javelin
two years after its introduction. An official says, "We fight to
raise athletes' daily food allowances from Rs 100 to Rs 118. Here money
is just being thrown away." Adds Ashwini Kumar: "This money
could have been spent on a sport like hockey in which we have a chance
of winning Olympic gold. How many artificial surfaces could you install
for this sum?"
|
THE GAMES WE SEE
|
|
# Tennis without Leander Paes and Mahesh
Bhupathi who will focus on the World Doubles hampionships being
held the same week.
# Hockey without Asian giants Pakistan
and Olympic silver medallists South Korea who will be playing in
the Champions Trophy in Lahore.
# Football teams without their star players
who will be in the midst of their European club seasons.
|
The Sport
Sadly but inevitably the core of the
Afro-Asian Games-the actual athletic competition-is farthest from everyone's
mind. Let alone the proposed cost, the very sporting merit of the event
is dubious. The games are neither recognised continental multi-discipline
events like the Asian Games nor are they an age-group event where young
talent could test itself against the world's best.
The Afro-Asian Games are awkwardly placed in
the international sporting calendar. They are in the middle of the international
club football season (when the best African and Asian players will be
in the lucrative European leagues), will clash with the tennis World Doubles
Championships, where India's Leander Paes and Mahesh Bhupathi hope to
be playing, and also overlap the Champions Trophy hockey where Pakistan
and South Korea are involved. The Indian hockey team is currently in training
and has targeted three major events: the World Cup qualifying competition,
the Champions Challenge and the World Cup. No one dismisses the Afro-Asian
Games in public, with Indian Hockey Federation (IHF) President K.P.S.
Gill telling INDIA TODAY, "Any international exposure is good for
the Indian team." However an IHF insider admits, "The Afro-Asian
Games are not the focus for the national team-the team is training to
peak for more important events." With Pakistan and Olympic silver
medallists Korea's best teams sure to be absent from the games, it is
equally unlikely that 2002 World Cup hosts Malaysia will put their best
squad into what is at best a hiccup in the hockey calendar.
|
|

|
|
|
CHIEF: Kalmadi (extreme left) celebrating IOC chief Juan Samaranch's
visit
|
The Indian Football squad would rather play in
the South Asian Football Federation Cup in Dhaka (now due to be postponed)
than get whipped by far-stronger opposition in front of home crowds. Athletics
and swimming are deep into off-season in November. Athletes from these
events who turn up will do so either under duress from their federations
or lured by fat appearance money cheques. And Kalmadi says, "All
the best athletes will come-we've ensured there are no conflicting games."
Thanks to the moguls of the Indian Olympic Association,
the Government is being asked to spend close to Rs 80 crore on the Afro-Asian
Games. The total budget for other sports expenses this year, (excluding
the Rs 20 crore handout for the Afro-Asian Games) is Rs 153 crore. The
mathematics tells its own story of lopsided priorities. Kalmadi defends
his association's venture saying, "These Games are not as expensive
as the Asian Games. The main benefit from them will be renovating stadia.
The rest is friendship." With apologies to Casablanca, this could
be the beginning of a very expensive friendship.
|
|