| |
BUSINESS: STOCK OPTIONS
Zero Sum Game
The stock market slump has blown the whistle on
the favoured tool for attracting and retaining employees
By Malini Goyal
|
|

|
|
|
BALACHANDER SEKHAR:
"I was expecting to make Rs 1-2 crore
in three years from my ESOP."
An IIT and IIM graduate, Sekhar
left SmithKline Beecham to join Go4i.com in December 1999.
His ESOP at the dotcom was worth Rs 45 lakh in Feb 2000.
He is now back to a brick-and-mortar job.
|
For Balachander
Sekhar, a 28-year-old IIT and IIM graduate, employee stock option plans
(ESOPs) was the ticket to realising his dreams. Early retirement, a world
tour, a farmhouse, a laid-back life with no need to chase savings, no
pressures to get a hefty increment-he expected his ESOP to give all this
and more. "I was hoping to make Rs 1-2 crore in three years from
ESOP," he says. Confident, he chucked a promising job with an MNC
to join a portal, Go4I.com. That was last year. Today, Sekhar is back
in the brick-and-mortar world with a foreign bank. His ESOP worth: negligible.
In March last year, Ravi Mehrotra (not his real
name) was allotted ESOP by NIIT Ltd. Trading at about Rs 1,600 in April
2000, the scrip zoomed to Rs 2,525 two months later. Still in the lock-in
period, he could not do anything but sit back and feel good. "I was
plain ecstatic seeing the stock price zoom to such a level," he says.
His wife did the calculation: 1,000 shares multiplied by Rs 2,525 equalled
Rs 25.25 lakh. Today, Mehrotra does not want to talk ESOP. His stock worth
has plummeted to Rs 4.96 lakh.
It's all in the mind-the calculation, the rising
value of the stocks and the consequent plummeting. But for those who have
lived through the ecstasy and orgasmic highs of their company's share
price, it is difficult digesting the dip in their stock value. "Emotionally,
employees have gone through a roller-coaster ride," says Avneet Jolly
of Hewitt Associates.
Walk through the corridors of any infotech biggie,
eavesdrop on any canteen gossip and you will surely get a more than passing
reference to the stock market crash. As stock prices plummet, it is not
just the investors who are mourning. The employees are moaning too. Not
exactly investors, their fortunes too have got closely linked to the stock
market performance of their company through stock options.
ESOPs are of various kinds but the most popular
in India are ones in which an employee is allotted shares of his company
at the market price and is given an option to purchase them after a certain
period. The employee is free to either buy the shares or decline the offer
at the end of that period. If he leaves the company before the end of
the period he foregoes the option. Thus ESOPs work as a retention tool
for companies.
ESOPs have been a big hit ever since the concept
was introduced in India three years back. Peons at Infosys becoming millionaires,
drivers at Satyam owning millions-such tales of quick success and easy
fortune have become part of folklore. It became fashionable for companies
to give out ESOPs, be it IT majors like Wipro, Infosys, HCL Technologies
and NIIT, progressive Indian firms like Ranbaxy, ICICI, SRF, Dabur and,
of course, the swelling number of MNCs here. Not to forget the dotcoms
who whipped up a frenzy, offering attractive ESOPs as part of the pay-packet
to lure professionals.
But the excitement has given way to depression.
The gloom of bearish stock markets is already showing up at corporate
corridors. "The demand for mid-sized cars in Bangalore is not as
healthy as it was last year," says B.V.R. Subbu, director, marketing,
Hyundai India. The city has probably the largest number of ESOP holders
in the country. And it was where the symptoms started showing first.
|

|
|
|
AMITABH BHAGAT: "ESOPs
meant a lot to me. I had expected a gain of Rs 16 lakh. I'm disappointed
now."
When Bhagat was offered ESOP at Wipro, its value
was Rs 16 lakh. His stock would have been worth Rs 13.5 lakh today
but he quit the company in August 2000.
|
|
It is not just money. ESOPs is fast losing their
effectiveness as an employee retention tool. Says an ex-Wipro employee:
"Whatever I lost on quitting the company, I more than made up in
my new job." In today's bearish markets, employees are figuring out
that they can pick up company stocks much cheaper directly from the market
rather than through ESOPs (see graph).
While brick-and-mortar companies are feeling
the heat, dotcomers are totally shattered. "I was bitten by the dotcom
bug. The huge stock options were a major attraction," says Sekhar.
He was not alone. Chasing ESOP dreams, many joined dotcoms, little realising
that without a listing on the stock markets, the ESOP meant nothing. "We
were making castles in the air," says Rajeev Saksena, an engineer
and an MBA who quit The Indian Express to join the portal JobsAhead.com.
Saksena still remembers the day when he got ESOPs. "I was excited.
My boss personally handed over the letter to me complimenting my work
and explaining its significance," he says. A third-party valuation
put his stock value at a staggering Rs 65 lakh. "Today it's worth
nothing," he says.
|
|

|
|
|
RAJEEV SAKSENA:
"I
was excited when I was told that my ESOP was worth Rs 65 lakh. Obviously,
we were building castles in
the air."
An engineer and MBA, Saksena
quit The Indian Express to join JobsAhead.com. As the dotcom bubble
burst, the value of his ESOPs came tumbling down and he left
the job in June 2000.
|
"It was a ruse by which a lot of companies
cheated candidates," says Ronesh Puri, managing director of headhunting
firm Executive Access. A number of dotcoms sold ESOPs aggressively to
employees, often persuading them to take a pay cut. This not only meant
a lower wage bill for a start-up but also made dotcom jobs attractive
for risk takers. But, of course, dotcoms were more hype than reality-few
survived the shake out and fewer came out with public issues.
But hr experts still believe in ESOPs. Says
Deepak Gupta, managing director, Korn/Ferry, an hr consultancy firm: "ESOPs
have survived many such market crashes in the US. They still hold."
The stock market crash has underlined the fact that ESOPs make employees
partners in the business, for better or worse. "ESOPs convert managers
into long-term owners of the company," says Sanjiv Kataria, senior
vice-president, NIIT Ltd.
And for those in gloom, here's a word of cheer
from Aadesh Goyal, vice-president, Hughes Software: "If anything,
the new low in the stock market is a good time to give stock options."
|
|