India Today Group Online
 


May 28, 2001
Issue


India Today, May 28, 2001

 

COVER
   

Convict Queen
Though AIADMK leader Jayalalitha was debarred from contesting the elections on grounds of her conviction in a corruption case, she was sworn in as chief minister of Tamil Nadu. Will her aggressive game plan work? And should popular mandate overrule judicial verdicts?

 

 
BUSINESS
   

Great Call Of China
Indian entrepreneurs are eagerly joining the swiftly growing queue to set up shop in China.
The land once considered forbidden has suddenly become
the hottest destination for Indian businessmen.

 

 
DIPLOMACY
   

Looking East
Atal Bihari Vajpayee's visit to Malaysia may have achieved little on Quattrochi's extradition and India's greater ties with ASEAN, but it showed there is more to their bilateral relations than these two issues.

 

 
STATES
 

Mother's Day
Stalinist methods played a vital role in the humiliating finale of M. Karunanidhi's dynastic ambition.

 

 
DEFENCE
 

Readying For Nukes For the first time after India became a nuclear power, the Army stages a nuclear war game to check preparedness.

 

 
OTHER STORIES
     
 



 
  Home  
 

FROM THE EDITOR IN CHIEF


India can be a confusing place. One minute you are chief minister of a state, next you lose an election. And then, you are charged with corruption, convicted and sentenced to jail. You appeal, your sentence is stayed but the conviction is pending appeal. Meanwhile, it's election time again but you are debarred from contesting by the local returning officer because of your conviction. Regardless, your party wins a landslide. And you become chief minister again-no matter that you have not been elected. Such is the strange tale of the indomitable Tamil politician Jayaram Jayalalitha.

So, you have the ridiculous situation in which you cannot contest an election but can become chief minister-or prime minister, for that matter.


Previous covers on Jayalalitha

When the founding fathers of India's Constitution charted out what it takes for a governor to invite a person to assume the office of chief minister, they made a simple assumption in Article 164: the governor can invite a person representing a political formation even if the person is not at the time of appointment a member of the legislature, provided the person can be elected within six months of the appointment. But nobody thought to add riders such as those disqualified won't count. Naive as it may seem, the founding fathers had never imagined that a situation warranting such riders would ever arise.

That a political mandate can override a judicial decision has very serious implications not just for Tamil Nadu but for the functioning of our democracy. For our cover story this week, we have traversed a cross-section of legal opinion to see whether Jayalalitha's appointment is correct. And if not, how the anomaly can be rectified. There is also the ticklish issue of what will happen six months later when she will need to be elected. What happens to the chief ministership if Jayalalitha is still debarred? And if the status is reversed, it will question the credibility of the Election Commission. What makes things worse is that there are still more than a dozen cases against Jayalalitha in various stages of prosecution. Since she has the power to change the public prosecutor it raises questions about the judicial process.

Obviously, the faith our Republic's founding fathers placed on the moral stature of our politicians was seriously misplaced.


(Aroon Purie)


 
 
 
Care Today
     METRO TODAY
 
   

MetroScape

Bands Blast
"United For Gujarat," a concert held recently at the Nehru Stadium, Delhi, brought together Sufi rock band Junoon from Pakistan, Euphoria and Silk Route from India and Bangla rock group Miles from Bangladesh to perform in aid of quake victims in Gujarat.
more...

Looking Glass

Delhi Art Gallery:
The Delhi Art Club

Delhi Cinema:
"Flicks Down Under"

Mumbai Restaurant:
Karma

Kolkata Restaurant:
Teej

 

 
    Web Exclusives
DESPATCHES
 

The Madhya Pradesh governor orders a CBI inquiry into a land allotment by the chief minister to the Nai Duniya group, kicking off a constitutional crisis. INDIA TODAY Special Correspondent Neeraj Mishra reports in
Conflict Of Interest.

 

 
PREVIOUS ISSUE


India Today, May 21, 2001

Click here to view
the previous issue

 

 

 


India Today | The Newspaper Today | Aaj Tak | Business Today | Computers Today | India Today Plus | Teens Today | Music Today
Art Today | Jokes & Toons | India Today Book Club | TNT Astro | TNT Movies
Care Today | E-Greetings| TNT Forums | Archives | Syndications

Write to us | About Us | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer

© Living Media India Ltd