India Today Group Online
 


July 09, 2001
Issue


 

COVER
   

Where Have All The Jobs Gone
Old jobs are being slashed and new ones have slowed down to a trickle. With corporate India shedding staff faster than ever before, the worst sufferers are freshers and middle-level managers.

 

 
THE NATION
   

Preparing For Musharraf
Administrators, securitymen and hospitality merchants gear up to ensure that it's not just the Taj that will impress the visiting
Pakistani President.

Adviser Raj
Bureaucrats don't retire. Their terms are extended or they are reappointed to counsel political mentors.

 

 
STATES
 

Out Of Luck Now
It will take more than voter-friendly symbolism to ensure victory in UP.

Hard Cover Up
The Government is perturbed by a cop's unreleased book on Rajkumar's kidnapping.


 
SCIENCE & TECH.
 

Connecting Bharat
It's a project to bridge the digital divide. But sources of funding are not known.

 

 
OTHER STORIES
     
 



 
  Home  
 

BOOKS

Memory Lapse

A stale product from the Partition industry.

 

The essays equate the Partition solely with Punjab

Pakistan and Partition ... always make good copy," says Saumya Gupta, one of the contributors to this volume of translations, commentaries and criticism. Is this why we've seen such a surge in the literature on the Partition in the past few years? Even so, shouldn't such literature, at the least, offer fresh perspectives on that traumatic splintering which not only coincided with our Independence, but cast its long shadow over whatever we've been doing or have done since? Sadly, I'm not sure if this brave effort actually manages to do that. Except for one somewhat fastidious, self-conscious, but original and engaging essay by Arjun Mahey, Translating Partition is at best a convenient teaching tool and useful compendium of already available views on the subject.

TRANSLATING PARTITION
Ed by Ravi Kant & Tarun K. Saint
Katha
Price: Rs 250
Pages: 238

Of course, you have new translations of well-known partition stories here, such as "Tetwal ka Kutta" and "Toba Tek Singh" by Saadat Hasan Manto, "Kitne Pakistan" by Kamleshwar, "Pali" by Bhisham Sahni, "Khayal Surat" by Surendra Prakash and "Dariyaon Pyasa" by Joginder Paul. This is definitely a positive sign.

In addition, the editors have also included an original English story, "Phoenix Fled" by Attia Hosain and a translation of "Dibacha", Manto's satirical foreword to Beghair Unwaan ke. The four critical commentaries in the second section are of varying competence, none striking or especially insightful. Again, nearly all the essays in the overview section do not necessarily reflect any special understanding or intuition. Moreover, this collection once again makes the mistake of equating the Partition solely with what happened in Punjab.

I won't end without some questions about Manto, who has emerged as the unquestioned "champion" of Partition authors. Is this because he is so utterly devoid of squeamishness and sentimentalism? Or because he offers an unblinking reflection of our own moral corruption? Or because a figure such as M.K. Gandhi is totally and deliberately absent from his work?


 
Search    



     METRO TODAY
 
   

MetroScape

The Art Of Fashion
Dance of the Kites, an oddball fashion show at the new Sheetal Design Studio store, elicited reactions like, "It's different and that doesn't need qualification" (singer Suneeta Rao) and "These couldn't be models, they're probably theatre artists!" (veteran model Anu Ahuja).
more...

Looking Glass

Mumbai Hotel:
Renaissance Mumbai Hotel and Convention Centre

Mumbai Tribal Art: Murias

Pune Multiplex:
City Pride

 

 
    Web Exclusives
DESPATCHES
 

Long considered politically naive, the Gujarat chief minister is a wiser man now. But the shrewdness would prove worthier if employed in matters of state, writes INDIA TODAY's Special Correspondent Uday Mahurkar in
Misplaced Guile

 

 
PREVIOUS ISSUE




Click here to view
the previous issue

 

 

 


India Today | The Newspaper Today | Aaj Tak | Business Today | Computers Today | India Today Plus | Teens Today | Music Today
Art Today | Jokes & Toons | India Today Book Club | TNT Astro | TNT Movies
Care Today | E-Greetings| TNT Forums | Archives | Syndications

Write to us | About Us | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer

© Living Media India Ltd