| |
BOOKS
The
National Mind
Making
sense of the idea of Hindutva
By Francois
Gautier
At
last, a book on hindutva written by someone who is knowledgeable, worldly,
well-versed in western culture and fluent in English. Western critics
of Hindutva have often made fun of the poor mastery of English and the
lack of academic knowledge of its proponents. Prafulla Goradia makes no
such mistakes-his book is full of references and annotations. Firstly,
what is Hindutva? "Hindutva," says Goradia, "is a dialectical
or logical concept which rests on the basic explanation of life given
by Hinduism or sanatan dharma." Yet, there is nothing particularly
Hindu about dharma. "After all, what civilised human being, whether
Muslim, Christian, Buddhist or Jain, would deny that he has a faith to
keep and a duty to perform?" And here Goradia reminds us of the greatest
trait of Hinduism: that it's not a religion, but a living universal spirituality,
probably the last of our planet.
|

|
|
|
THE SAFFRON BOOK
By Prafulla Goradia
Contemporary Target
Price: Rs 240
Pages: 327
|
|
No nation can rise without a degree of nationalism.
India has been colonised, raped, humiliated, bled economically for centuries:
"swaraaj is our ultimate goal and the way to achieve this objective
is with the help of nationalism," he writes. And who was India's
greatest nationalist? Sri Krishna, "who first personified the unity
of India by becoming president of the confederation of five Yadava republican
committees". Goradia places great emphasis on temples destroyed by
Muslim invaders. For some it might be unnecessarily raking up past animosities,
but for Goradia it is not only a matter of re-establishing historical
truth, but also of restoring India's pride. Nothing for the author symbolises
more the desecration and humiliation of India than Ajmer: "there
is not a single statue there whose face has not been cut off. Nowhere
in Europe did one see such acts of vandalism."
Of
course, this book will not convince everybody, specially many western
India specialists who have made an art (and a living) of Hindu bashing
for 50 years. France's leading Indologist Christophe Jaffrelot, for instance,
who has consistently advised France's political intelligentsia that the
BJP Government is "fascist and fundamentalist" (which is why
French prime minister Lionel Jospin hasn't bothered to visit India), lambasted
the book, calling it "full of contradictions". But it is a must
-read for those who want to understand the Hindu psyche.
|
|