| |
THE NATION: GOVERNMENT
Is Arun Indispensable?
|
|
THE LINE OF FIRE
|
| |
GROUSE: Arun Singh has been given an "extra-constitutional"
role in the Defence Ministry, behaves like a supercrat.
RESPONSE: The Ministry of Defence (MoD) says he has been
scrutinised by intelligence agencies and is accountable to Parliament
through Jaswant Singh.
GROUSE: Is seen as pushing Jaswant for an early creation
of the CDS structure despite objections from the Finance Ministry
and the Cabinet Secretariat.
RESPONSE: The MoD says it is all for the CDS, feels that
future warfare will involve synergised operations.
GROUSE: Arun is seen as playing favourites in key appointments
to the Defence and External Affairs ministries.
RESPONSE: He is the backroom boy, says the MoD. He sticks
to his task on defence and strategic issues, does not interfere
in transfers and postings.
|
That special rapport
has already had an impact on the priorities Jaswant has set for the external
affairs and defence ministries. Conscious of the geopolitical changes
in India's neighbourhood-particularly the economic and political assertion
of China-the combine of Jaswant and Arun is placing special emphasis on
building relationships with global players. That includes involving the
military establishment in the strategic dialogue between India and countries
such as the United States and Australia. Arun's old contacts are apparently
helpful when dealing with the US. It isn't surprising that bureaucrats
heading the Americas and nuclear policy divisions in the External Affairs
Ministry look towards Arun for advice on issues ranging from theatre missile
defence to American moves on the China-Taiwan situation.
Defence analyst K. Subrahmanyam, who headed
the Kargil Review Committee, says Arun is "steeped" in defence
matters and is an asset to a country that does not have enough security
experts. He dismisses charges of "non-accountability" against
Arun, saying the adviser is accountable to Parliament through his minister.
"If Rakesh Mohan, adviser to the finance minister, can sit in meetings
with top finance officials, including the finance secretary, then why
can't Arun have meetings with the three service chiefs? The present chiefs
may have been colonels or brigadiers when he was in charge of the ministry
earlier," he says.
Arun
Singh's rapport with Jaswant has impacted the MoD's priorities.
|
|
Arun has also given a fillip to a proposal that
requires arms agents to register with the MoD. The path-breaking proposal
envisages that even agents representing arms manufacturing companies that
do not have an office in India officially deal with the MoD. Earlier,
only those companies with branches in India dealt with the government.
The move will not only break the nexus between arms dealers, pliant politicians,
bureaucrats and service officers but also bring a degree of transparency
to the procurement of defence equipment.
Although the MoD is giving a final shape to
the arms procurement proposal, the appointment of Special Secretary Ajay
Vikram Singh and Financial Adviser Gyan Prakash to the equipment acquisition
wing has raised eyebrows. South Block gossip has it that Arun pushed the
case of these two bureaucrats in the proposed procurement board as they
had worked under him during his earlier stint as minister. While Ajay
was serving in Uttaranchal prior to his posting, Prakash had hit the headlines
when George Fernandes, as the defence minister, sent him to the Siachen
glacier for delaying the snow-scooters proposal for the army.
Arun is reportedly dismayed at the spate of
criticism coming his way and has indicated that he wouldn't like to hang
on to his position any longer than it demands. He is impatient with the
bureaucratic delay in appointing the CDS and has requested Jaswant to
take up the issue again with the prime minister. He would dearly love
to head back to the hills but Jaswant seems unwilling to do without his
friend's advice. And the need to stay on till the major reforms that he
has suggested are seen through is a compelling plea. So barring a two-week
sojourn in Almora next week, Arun is likely to spend the coming winter
holed up in his office in South Block.
|
|