| |
BOOKS
No Yaar, This Is Asoka
Good pictures but potted history of the king and
his times is an insult to the subject
By Bhaskar Ghose
One of the advantages of writing a coffee-table
book like this one is that you can put in a whole lot of stuff which may
or may not stand up to scrutiny because you know that hardly anyone reads
it. What they do is look at the pictures. So if you have some attractive
pictures, you're made. Actually, many people don't look at the pictures
either. They just keep the book on-yes-a coffee table or any convenient
place where guests can see it, or, better still, they repack it and give
it as a present to someone.
|
|
|
THE MAKING OF ASOKA
By Mushtaq Sheikh
HarperCollins
Price: Rs 995
Pages: 159
|
Mushtaq Sheikh
uses his hi-yaar style to present a potted history of Asoka and his times,
and then, in a chapter titled, would you believe it, "Myth O'Logic"
he lays out some of the legends about Asoka with a breeziness that helps
you flip through the pages faster than you otherwise would, pausing-but
only briefly-to look at some of the sketches. Some of these have
pleasing lines, but lack any semblance of life. However, as if to compensate,
in between the chapters are sketches by
M.F. Husain; none of them will make you fall off your chair, but they
do have the artist's deft touch.
The photographs are spectacular enough; scenes
from the film are juxtaposed with some diverting shots of director Santosh
Sivan, actors, actresses and crew, and succeed in giving the reader (viewer?)
a fair idea of the atmosphere during the shooting of the film. There are
some very attractive photographs of Shah Rukh Khan as Asoka, and some
reasonable ones of the others. One, in particular, of Kareena Kapoor as
Kaurwaki, the princess, preparing for battle holds your attention because
it's the only one where there's a bit of character showing.
The rest of the book consists of interviews
with the principals and, of course, the director, and anecdotes about
the making of the film. This part-the major section of the narrative-is
the most disorganised. The different pieces stay disparate, never coming
together to suggest what the making of the film involved.
The interviews with the director and Shah Rukh
are reasonably well done; both give you small doses of their "View
on Life", but then all film people think they're expected to do so,
so you don't have to spend too much time on them. Kareena's interview
is the silliest of the lot. Short of actually saying, "Who's this
Ashok guy, yaar, what a bore, yaar", whatever she says is in that
vein. Juhi Chawla, on the other hand, is cheerful and sparkling in her
answers; a sensible young woman, who obviously took her job as the producer
seriously.
Shiekh obviously thought no one would read his
copy; he was mistaken and that's the part of the book that can be safely
passed over.
|
|
|
Gandhi:
A Sublime Failure
By S.S. Gill
(Rupa, Rs 295)
An insight into the Mahatma's non-successes despite his universal
appeal.
|
|
Dahan
(The Burning)
By Suchitra Bhattacharya
(Srishti, Rs 195)
Of two women's search for justice in a man's world.
|
|
The
Lucknow Omnibus
By Abdul Halim Sharar, Rosie Llewellyn-Jones and Veena Talwar Oldenburg
(Oxford, Rs 495)
The history and culture that shaped the legendary city.
|
|
Civil
Lines, Vol 5
Ed by Kai Friese and Mukul Kesavan
(IndiaInk, Rs 250)
India's Granta introduces more new talents.
|
|
Jungle
By-ways in India
By E.P. Stebbing
(Nataraj, Rs 450)
Of forests and the wildlife it sustained a 100 years ago.
|
|
|