India Today Group Online
 


November 05, 2001
Issue


 

COVER
   

How Long Will The
War Last?

Three weeks into the world's most high tech war and the Taliban regime has not crumbled. Instead, there seems to be discordant noises from America over the strategic objectives of the campaign. With the Northern Alliance advance halted and diplomacy making slow progress, this is a war that could run on and on. An EXCLUSIVE report.

 
STRATEGY
   

Advantage Outsiders
With the balance tilted against it, the Taliban regime will soon find itself vanquished.

 

 
DESPATCH
 

Lull Before The Storm
Amid calls for a quick and decisive end to the conflict, Afghanistan has been abuzz with talk of an imminent Northern Alliance ground war against the Taliban.

 
RUSSIA
 

History's Pointers
The Soviet Union's 10 years campaign in Afghanistan — a conflict that led to a humiliating withdrawal and, some say, its eventual breakup
— can be a learning experience for
the US.

 

 
OTHER STORIES
     
 



 
 
Home 
 
 

BOOKS

Monumental Waste

One more from the Raj nostalgia industry but this one is mundane history

Once the greatest imperial power, Britain is today the world's foremost heritage state. It is a place where everything old is lovingly preserved-well, almost everything. From reconditioned Shanks commodes to the National Trust properties, preservation is Albion's way of life. Which is why Britons are both saddened and infuriated by the Indian disregard of heritage. To Britons, the Raj is both nostalgia and commerce; to cretinous Indians, it is just prime real estate awaiting "development".

LEARNING THE WAYS EARLY: Schoolboys on the Mail, Darjeeling

Of course, it wasn't always like this. Before Lord Curzon established the Archaeological Survey of India and made preservation a part of the loftier goals of the Empire, the conquering British were vandals. Very much like the conquerors from Central Asia who preceded them. Robert Clive helped himself to priceless goodies from the palace in Murshidabad and Lord Bentinck even contemplated shifting the Taj Mahal block by block to England-the economics of transportation saved the monument.

REMAINS OF THE RAJ: THE BRITISH LEGACY IN INDIA
By Antony Wild
HarperCollins/Rupa
Price: Rs 1,096
Pages: 240

Since Raj nostalgia hit Britain in the 1980s-some date it to the spectacular success of the TV version of Paul Scott's Jewel In The Crown-it is redemption time. From endless newspaper articles on the last railway engine from Chakradharpur (pronounced Chuck-udder-pore) to endless coffee-table glossies, the Raj has been reinvented for a people who no longer think they won the first prize in the lottery of life by being born English.

Predictably, the quality is uneven. Robert FermorHesketh's photographs of the Architecture of the British Empire (1986) and Jan Morris and Simon Winchester's Stones of the Empire (1983) set exacting standards. These have been matched by the spectacular Smithsonian Institute-sponsored India Through the Lens, Photography 1840-1911, published last year. Against these, Antony Wild's offering is a complete non-starter.

That Wild is a Raj admirer isn't in any doubt. He is the chairman of the East India Company PLC, a company inspired by the original thing. However, it is one thing to love the Empire, and a different ball game adding to the sum total of knowledge about it. In addition, Wild is guilty of what many would regard as a misrepresentation. Entitled Remains of the Raj, the photographs-not terribly classy or out of the way-are about British monuments as they stand in today's India. Logically, the text should have centred on the lingering presence of the Raj. Sadly, it is a mundane history of British rule.

Writing on the Raj legacy entails a knowledge of both history and contemporary Indian society. Wild's understanding of the latter is fleeting. Which is why this book is destined to find a place in the remaindered sections of bookshops.

NEW RELEASES

Healing Plants of Peninsular India
By J.A. Parrotta
(CABI, $140)
Botanical description of 550 plant species.

Bin Laden: The Man Who Declared War on America
By Yossef Bodansky
(Forum, Rs 675)
The chilling story of the rise of the radical Islamist.

Civil Society: History and Possibilities
Ed by Sudipta Kaviraj, Sunil Khilnani
(Cambridge, Rs 795)
Essays on how this western idea is modified by the intellectual contexts of other societies.

A Birdwatcher's Guide to India
By Krys Kazmierczak & Raj Singh
(Oxford, Rs 395)
A site guide with details of uncommon species.

Forsaking Paradise
By Abdul Ghani Sheikh
(Katha, Rs 150)
Stories that give a rare glimpse of Ladakhi society by one of the region's foremost writers.


 
Search    



     METRO TODAY
 
   

MetroScape

Class Of 2001
Watching a fashion show by design students is sometimes like viewing a commercial Hindi film. Don't dissect the logic; enjoy the show if you can.
more...


Looking Glass

Mumbai Restaurant:
India Jones

Mumbai Puppetry Festival: Toccata

Bangalore Restaurant: Chung Wah

Kolkata Exhibition : Life Is Beautiful

 

 
    Web Exclusives
DESPATCHES
  Bonefix is generally used to fix soles to shoes. But at the Bhopal Railway Station, it affords young children an escape from their nondescript lives. INDIA TODAY's Special Correspondent
Neeraj Mishra finds out why in
Early High

 

 
PREVIOUS ISSUE




Click here to view
the previous issue

 

 

 


India Today | The Newspaper Today | Aaj Tak | Business Today | Computers Today | India Today Plus | Teens Today | Music Today
Art Today | Jokes & Toons | India Today Book Club | TNT Astro | TNT Movies
Care Today | E-Greetings| TNT Forums | Archives | Syndications

Write to us | About Us | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer

© Living Media India Ltd