|
PAKISTAN: TUSSLE WITHIN
The Double Game
As the war drags on, the US discovers the perils
of allying with a dictator who wants to appear a statesman abroad and
a politician at home
By Shishir Gupta with Hasan Zaidi in Islamabad and Anil
Padmanabhan in Washington
Four
weeks into the war against terrorism, there are growing signs of frustration
and concern in Washington DC over its inability to achieve a significant
military breakthrough in Afghanistan. The bombing of terrorist territory
may have begun on October 7 but there is no sign of Osama bin Laden or
top Al Qaida cadre. Taliban leader Mullah Omar remains elusive. Finally,
the formation of a viable political alternative to the Taliban appears
far and distant.
American exasperation hasn't been helped by General
Pervez Musharraf. The Pakistani President shot his mouth off on everything
from the duration of the war to ceasing hostilities during Ramzan. American
officials lost no time in contradicting their favourite dictator.
|
MUSHARRAF SPEAK
|
|
The US military
action is expected to be short.
AT A PRESS MEET IN ISLAMABAD, OCT 8
One would hope
for restraint during the month of Ramzan.
INTERVIEW TO CNN, OCT 23
I have four parameters
for the future Afghanistan government.
INTERVIEW TO CNN, OCT 23
|
|
ALLIES' RESPONSE
|
The one way to
shorten it is for Bin Laden to be handed over.
US PRESIDENT GEORGE W. BUSH, OCT
10
Muslim nations
have fought on important holy days in the past.
US DEFENCE SECRETARY RUMSFELD, OCT 23
The next government
in Kabul cannot be decided by Pakistan.
SECRETARY OF STATE COLIN POWELL, OCT 25
|
A week ago, General Tommie R. Franks, the US
commander in the Afghanistan theatre, visited Islamabad. He was concerned
at the quality of intelligence being provided by Pakistan. General Franks
was apparently fairly blunt in his one-to-one meeting with Musharraf.
Later he met the entire Pakistan military brass, including the air force
and navy chiefs. Here he conveyed the US "request" for additional
logistical support, including more air bases, for the second phase of
the Afghan war.
The Americans are particularly alarmed at the
killing of Abdul Haq, the former mujahideen commander. Haq was in Afghanistan
on a CIA-backed mission to divide the Taliban but was supposedly betrayed
(see box) by rogue elements in Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence
(ISI).
To offset doubts about both his commitment as
an ally and his grip on his country, Musharraf issued a strong statement
at the conclusion of General Franks' visit. "Who is the head of the
Pashtoons?" he said to Reuters Television. "Not the Taliban.
It is a very calculated remark that I am making." The general was
obviously hinting at a split in the Taliban ranks to allay western worries.
Actually, he need not have bothered. Despite
some voices to the contrary, the broad US perception is that the General
himself is supportive of the war effort. In the words of Dennis Kux, former
US ambassador to Pakistan, "Musharraf is a case of 'what you see
is what you get'. Fairly straightforward."
|
|
| FAITH IN SOLIDARITY: Armed Pakistanis on
their way to the Afghan frontier to fight against the US. Almost 5,000
men have gathered at the Temergarah village on the border. |
The leaks and disinformation are blamed on Taliban
sympathisers lower down in the Pakistan Army and the ISI. The intelligence
agency is a convenient villain. News reports from Washington have even
charged the intelligence agency-once described as "a state within
a state"-with using Al Qaida camps in Afghanistan to train "covert
operatives for use in the war of terror against India".
The immediate worries for Washington are the
porous Pakistan-Afghanistan border, protests in the streets of Pakistan
and fear of nuclear weapons falling into terrorist hands (see box). The
Durand Line which divides Pakistan and Afghanistan has become a lifeline
for the Taliban. There are regular reports of men and material making
their way to Mullah Omar's militia. Pakistani cleric Sufi Mohammed confirmed
that 10,000 armed tribesmen-ethnic cousins of the Afghan Pashtoons-are
gathered in the Malakant Agency of the North-West Frontier Province (NWFP),
ready to fight in the defence of Kabul.
The capture of the Chilas airstrip in Pakistan
by Pashtoon tribesmen recently was meant to prevent the US from launching
helicopter operations. The blocking of the strategic Karakoram highway
by NWFP tribals for five days was another demonstration of Pashtoon power
to the West.
|
DEADLY DUPLICITY
|
|
THE POROUS BORDER
MUSHARRAF SAYS that Pakistan has sealed the border with Afghanistan,
allowing only humanitarian aid to pass through.
THE REALITY: The border between Pakistan and Afghanistan
has become the lifeline for the Taliban, with men, material and
hospitals at the service of Mullah Omar's militia.
FRIENDLY FIRE
MUSHARRAF SAYS Pakistan will help the US-led coalition
in its war against the Taliban and allow it to use its air bases.
THE REALITY: The Chilas airstrip in Pakistan was captured
by Pashtoon tribesmen to prevent the US from launching helicopter
operations. US helicopters taking off from an air base in Baluchistan
were fired upon.
LOGISTICAL SUPPORT
PAKISTAN IS supposed to provide logistical and intelligence
support to the coalition forces in the war.
THE REALITY: The quality of the information provided to
the US forces is suspect. Besides, there are information leaks,
like that of an impending commando raid on the Taliban stronghold
of Kandahar.
SUPPORT TO NORTHERN ALLIANCE
PAKISTAN SAYS any wholehearted support to the Tajik and
Hazara-led Northern Alliance would unite Pashtoons against the US.
THE REALITY: The Alliance is no friends of the Pakistani
establishment and a Kabul in its control would be hostile to Islamabad.
So the defence of Kabul is an undeclared Pakistani cause.
|
If that were not enough, US helicopters taking
off from the Dal Bandin air base in Baluchistan were fired upon. Information
about a commando raid on Kandahar, the Taliban stronghold in south Afghanistan,
was leaked. Fighting a war out of Pakistan has put the US in the line
of a strange variant of friendly fire.
Being hypersensitive to Musharraf has also meant
Washington hasn't been able to decide a clear-cut role for the Northern
Alliance. The chief anti-Taliban grouping in Afghanistan, the Alliance
controls 10 per cent of the country's territory. In a conventional war,
the US would simply have backed its enemy's enemy and dealt with the consequences
later.
In this war, however, the US has been unable
to shrug off Pakistan's concerns about the role of the Northern Alliance.
Islamabad tried to convince Washington about faultlines within the Alliance
by projecting differences between Uzbek warlord Abdul Rashid Dostum, Tajik
commander Fahim Khan and the Northern Alliance's Foreign Minister Abdullah
Abdullah. Any wholehearted support to the Alliance, Pakistan warned, would
also consolidate the Pashtoons against America. The US is also pinning
hopes on mujahideen leader Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, another Pashtoon, who
is currently in Iran.
The US was not totally convinced by the Pakistani
logic. It went ahead with a $50 million aid package to Dostum. It wants
the Uzbek veteran to wrest the strategic town of Mazar-e-Sharif in north
Afghanistan and help US ground operations. Since Dostum does not have
access to a land corridor for refurbishing military supplies, the attack
on Mazar-e-Sharif has still not happened.
|