|
In 1995,
Shahir Hussain drove his car three times over sister-in-law Tasleem Begum
Sadiq. Later, his conviction for murder was overturned when he pleaded
guilty to a less severe charge of manslaughter on the grounds of provocation.
Sadiq's provocation was that she had left Hussain's brother whom she was
forced to marry.
Rukhsana Naz from Derby met the same fate. Forced to marry a cousin in
Pakistan when she was 15, she managed to return to England assuring her
husband a settlement visa in the UK. One day her abusive mother pushed
her on the floor and her brother put a ligature around her neck. Within
minutes she was strangled. Her crime: she was pregnant from a boy she
intended to marry. For the conservative Muslim community in Derby, she
had committed the ultimate crime of adultery, bringing shame and dishonour
to the family that could only be salvaged by Naz's inevitable death.
 |
|
"There is a wall of silence hiding the
real magnitude of the problem."
Ann Cryer MP from Keighley, who has been a vocal opponent
of forced marriages
|
These are not isolated cases. Marrying daughters within their own caste
or community has been one of the biggest concerns among many Hindus, Sikhs
and Muslims-an obsession that often results in forced marriage of hundreds
of Asian girls in the UK.
Figures published this month by the Government showed that the foreign
office and police investigated at least 200 cases of young women and men
forced into marriages abroad in the last one year. This is the tip of
the iceberg, says Southall Black Sisters (SBS), a group at the forefront
of challenging forced marriages and domestic violence within the Asian
community. The SBS also gets about 200 requests every year for help from
women, either forced into marriage or living in fear of a marriage abroad.
|
"Those couple of hours
were terrifying."
Narina Anwar, 20
|
|
In
July 2000, Narina and Samina, who are 20 and 19 years old, and a
younger minor sister, were taken to visit their grandparents in
a village in Gujarat district of Pakistan. Soon after, a number
of "ugly and illiterate" men were paraded as "suitable
boys". The sisters refused to be coerced into marriage; Narina
even went on a hungerstrike. Then threats followed with their own
mother showing them a rifle. One day when the family was away attending
a funeral in a nearby village, the girls escaped. "We covered
our faces and walked 15 minutes to take a rickshaw to the nearby
town. There we hired a taxi to Lahore. In that two-and-a-half hours
journey the taxidriver made us nervous with his questions,"
says Narina. They silenced him with Rs 1,300. In Lahore, they went
to a cyber café, e-mailed their friends in the UK and managed
to call the British High Commission in Islamabad. "Those couple
of hours were terrifying," recalls Narina. The British consular
arranged a "safe" hotel for them and six days later, the
sisters were flown to London and sheltered in a refuge. "It
was very traumatic," says Narina, who has now joined the foreign
office campaign to save victims of forced marriages.
|
Muslim Women's Helpline in London also gets thousands of calls from girls
wanting to escape forced marriages. The problem is most acute in the Muslim-dominated
Yorkshire town, Bradford. During the last five years West Yorkshire Police
have dealt with more than 1,350 referrals. In 1995, they dealt with 144
and in 2000 there were 272.
Initial attempts to raise this issue were brushed aside in the name
of cultural sensitivities. Early immigrants from India and Pakistan came
mainly from a rural background. Many of them had little education and
low-paid jobs that gave them little opportunity to grow. They hoped to
save money and return home, a wish they could never fulfil.
Their inability to look beyond their social order stopped them from
mixing with the host community. Many parents, says Najma Ebrahim of the
Muslim Women's Helpline, were "scared of society here" and they
wanted to save their children, particularly girls, from the "decadent
values and corrupting influence of the western society."
But their children, to live and succeed in the world outside, had to
adapt to the western ways of life. The younger generation-industrious
and ambitious-was determined to move out of cultural ghettoes, such as
Southall, Bradford and Leicester, and explore the wider world.
The problem was first highlighted by the high profile case of Jack and
Zena, who had to be on the run for about seven years, while Zena's Muslim
parents tried to hunt them down across the country. As the incidents of
forced marriages increased, the Government took its first step to end
the practice in August 1999. A working group, co-chaired by two Asian
peers-Lord Nasir Ahmed and Baronness Pola Uddin-was appointed to consult
widely with the one million-strong Asian community in the UK. The need
for such an inquiry was further demonstrated by a court ruling that parents
who took their children overseas to be wed should face charges of abduction.
 |
|
No force: UK police officials with Indian police
as they visit Punjab in a bid to understand the Indian community
better
|
|
The law is being tightened to make it clear
that parents who force their children to marry may face kidnapping
and abduction charges.
|
Assures British Home Office Minister Mike O'Brien, "There can be
no compromise on the fundamental rights of these women but at the same
time we need to be sensitive to the community's needs. But multicultural
sensitivity cannot be an excuse for moral blindness."
Based on the working group report, the Government launched an action
plan in August 2000. Foreign Office Minister Baroness Scotland said the
Government needed "to send an unequivocal message to parents that
forcing children into marriage is wrong. It is not a legitimate cultural
tradition and has nothing to do with love or religious practice".
The plan initiated a £350,000 project to develop links between
the UK Police and key forces in Punjab (India), Mirpur (Pakistan-occupied
Kashmir) and Bangladesh. To enforce the law, special teams were set up
in British embassies and these teams had forged elaborate contacts with
the local police and NGOs.
A dedicated Community Liaison Unit (CLU) was set up in the Foreign Office
to work on behalf of the victims of forced marriage. And the law was being
tightened to make it clear that parents who force their children to marry
may face kidnapping and abduction charges.
Recently a conference on forced marriages organised by the West Yorkshire
Police brought together representatives of 10 police forces from England,
Scotland and Wales and CLU. Invitees were stunned to hear the story of
the escape of Narina Anwar and her two sisters from a village in Pakistan
(see box).
In the Asian-dominated Bradford, the police had formed a Missing Persons
Forced Marriage sub-group. According to Inspector Martin Baines, this
sub-group has "allowed an effective dialogue with the Asian community
about how to best deal with individual cases of forced marriage".
They are now in regular touch with the Punjab Police.
The police are dealing with a rising number of Asian women in the Bradford
area leaving their homes. A specialist officer liase between each women
and her family. Says Baines, "We treat such cases in a very sensitive
manner and we are not in the business of dividing families."
Despite such efforts the problem continues. Last July, Dinpreet (name
changed), a college student, was taken to Jindyala in Punjab to visit
her grandparents. She was threatened to be thrown into the well if she
refused to marry "someone already chosen for me". With no communication
for weeks, her Jamaican boyfriend in London frantically tired to contact
the British High Commission in Delhi. The authorities with the help of
the Punjab Police were able to fly her back to London. Still traumatised,
she says, "My family has disowned me. None of them speak to me."
She is now trying to rebuild her life alone.
A lot of community elders find nothing wrong in marrying off their daughters
in India or Pakistan. What is more scary is the use of "bounty hunters"-young
men who chase, threaten and sometimes forcefully bring back girls who
have run away. Ann Cryer, MP for Keighley, believes that there is "a
wall of silence" hiding the real magnitude of the problem. Before
the June polls, she was even warned of loosing her seat because her campaign
was seen as having a spoiling influence on young Asian girls.
So what is the escape route? Before going on holiday "let somebody
in Britain know; keep your passports and ticket with you; get the phone
numbers of the local consul and foreign office," suggests Dinpreet.
As for the Muslim community, the message is unequivocal. Says Ebrahim,
"Islam condemns forced marriage."
Reviewing the action plan a year on, Home Office Minister Angela Eagle
said she wanted to send a message to parents that the Government is determined
to stop this "terrible practice." Let's hope such parents do
get the message-the sooner the better.
|