|
Not
many will mourn the passing of 2001 but in the A.B. Vajpayee household
there will be an extra deep sigh of relief. He could not have had a more
horrible year. Not only did nothing go right for him or his Government,
but the gods seemed to conspire to make everything go wrong. The year
began with Tehelka and those unforgettable images of Vajpayee's handpicked
party president greedily stashing away ill-gotten money. And, ended with
the Government's own auditor pronouncing that officials in the Defence
Ministry had wasted more than Rs 1,000 crore on unneeded defence purchases.
The Kargil war, said the CAG, was the excuse for not following normal
checks but the war was over long before the ministry's purchases arrived.
Most Indians continue to puzzle over why we needed to spend $2,500 each
on coffins that could have been made in India for almost nothing. It was
the proverbial last nail in the Vajpayee Government's credibility but
the misfortunes 2001 brought did not end there as we saw from the December
13 terrorist attack on Parliament.
So the last days of this cruellest of years saw war clouds gathering
over the subcontinent and Vajpayee in the most unenviable position he
has ever been in. If he does not avenge the attack on Parliament, he will
look like a wimp in the eyes of Indians and if he does attack Pakistan,
he will look irresponsible in the eyes of the world.
He
has not had much luck in 2001. But if it has begun to change Pakistan
might save him-and the subcontinent-from a very ugly escalation by making
sincere efforts to close down groups like the Lashkar-e-Toiba and the
Jaish-e-Mohammed. If all we get from General Pervez Musharraf is the usual
bluster and bravado and if another major terrorist strike follows, Vajpayee
will have no option but military action. Cynics say that with elections
in Uttar Pradesh due early next year and with the abysmal quality of his
leadership, he already has no choice but to go for it. Jingoism always
unites India and in Uttar Pradesh it could unite the Hindu vote.
The euphoria, though, does not last long and since a decisive victory
is unlikely, war will serve only a limited purpose. At the end of the
war, if it takes place at all, Vajpayee will still have to examine why
he has been such an uninspiring leader. Without reducing the argument
to a facetious level, may I recommend that he consult Aamir Khan on improving.
Before writing this piece, I had the pleasure of watching the Britannia-Lagaan
cricket match in Mumbai last week. The Lagaan team won, as it did in the
movie, and at the end of it Khan and his team sang and danced for the
vast crowd. The songs from the movie are patriotic anyway but with Khan
doing the singing in real life the Brabourne Stadium became for a few
moments an extraordinary spectacle of nationalistic fervour. So incredible
was the audience reaction that it caused more than a few spectators to
wonder aloud why our political leaders found it so hard to strike a similar
chord.
In the old days when Vajpayee was just an opposition leader, he could
do what Khan did effortlessly and at a more serious level. What has gone
wrong since he became prime minister? Many, many things, of which the
most crucial continues to be the fact that he has made no effort to change
methods of governance and the average Indian is sick and tired of the
old ways. We can, for instance, no longer afford a government that spends
more on itself than it does on improving the lot of ordinary Indians.
We cannot afford a government that borrows so recklessly that it spends
more than 70 per cent of its revenue on servicing its debts. When you
consider that out of what is left, we spend a huge amount on defence (often
it turns out on the wrong things), you do not need to be an economist
to know that there cannot be much left for roads, schools, hospitals or
drinking water. Everyone knows that this is wrong but nobody in the Vajpayee
Government makes any effort to change things.
There has not been even the smallest attempt to reduce the size of the
government. So we continue to waste taxpayers' money on ministries like
Information & Broadcasting that became obsolete long ago. Armies of
obstructing officials man offices and institutions that exist for no valid
reason. Meanwhile, the only improvements that we see in the quality of
our lives come in areas that the Government has decided to stay out of.
The result is that the Government has become India's biggest NPA (non-performing
asset). This can only change if Vajpayee realises how important leadership
is when you take on the prime minister's job. He has spent the first two
years of his tenure behaving as if he were a chairman in gracious retirement.
With three years still to go, he needs to understand that his role is
not simply ceremonial but executive and the country is desperate for executive
action.
|