|
Imagine
a new state with about 20 million people-a population equal to that of
Haryana-joining India. Its people descend from Indians coming from all
regions, religions, and castes, including the offspring of indentured
labourers, unskilled workers, farmers, businessmen and educated professionals.
They are almost fully literate, with a per capita income exceeding $15,000.
They run several of the world's largest banks, airlines, consulting and
accounting firms, the most prestigious high technology companies, teach
in the best universities,and excel in science, engineering, and software.
The new state produces goods and services worth more than $300 billion
annually, or about twothirds of the entire output produced by the one
billion people living in India today.
This imaginary state describes the Indians, and their descendants, who
live outside India. The Indian diaspora thrives in all corners of the
world where it is typically better educated and wealthier than the local
population. It is heavily represented in the emerging technologies driving
the economies of developed countries, contributing disproportionately
to the world's prosperity. The growing pool of talent that India exports
to the rest of the world enriches other countries but does it help India
as well? The answer depends largely on whether India is ready to take
advantage of its distant kin.
Emigration
from India used to be considered a "brain drain" but reality
is more complicated. Most people who left India were neither wealthy nor
well educated until recent times, and many who succeed abroad would likely
have failed or attained mediocrity at best had they stayed home. Even
in historical times, India's inability to develop and fully utilise the
talents of its population spurred many of its energetic people to seek
better opportunities outside. For example, Indian mathematicians created
the decimal system about 1,500 years ago. Soon afterwards, Indian astronomers
and mathematicians emigrated to Baghdad, the Silicon Valley of the time,
to work in the courts of Arab rulers, developing mathematical applications.
Those who left India correctly judged that foreign rulers and institutions
would give them greater scope and opportunity to develop than those at
home. The fruits of their labour ultimately passed from the Arabs to the
Europeans, which quickly saw the superiority of a decimal system over
Roman Numerals. Medieval Indian scientific and mathematical knowledge
helped the world but did very little for India.
Is India fated to export talented people, often after giving them a
highly subsidised education, for the benefit of more developed countries
but not itself ? Fortunately, the example of the IT sector shows that
ethnic Indians abroad can help both India and the world. Indian IT would
not have developed had Indians not gone abroad to study and work. Today,
the IT sector exports more than $6 billion, boosting foreign exchange
reserves and creating well-paying jobs in the private sector. It benefits
from government investment in education but is run by the private sector
and is not politicised like most industries. It is open to foreign investment
and closely connected to ethnic Indian-run companies, venture capital
funds and businessmen in other countries. Its success helps legitimise
the capitalist pursuit of wealth in India, for people see that the new
IT millionaires earn their money through enterprise and not corruption
and connections.
Thesuccess of ethnic Indians abroad has political implications. The
prosperous businessman, doctor and software programmer is replacing snake
charmers and corrupt bureaucrats as the image of India. India is now known
not just for poverty but also for technological prowess in certain fields.
Ethnic Indians are becoming an increasingly effective lobby, especially
in the US, on India-related matters, a welcome improvement over diplomats.
India can take advantage of the skills and knowledge of its diaspora
or block access to it through restrictive laws, regulations and attitudes.
If Indians prosper in other countries with open, fiercely competitive
market economies, often rising to the top, what prevents the one billion
people in India from succeeding just as well? Faced with competition,
why do Indian businessmen seek shelter behind tariffs to preserve their
inefficient practices when their diaspora counterparts succeed without
them? Why do many Indians remain insecure about truly opening their economy
to multinationals when an increasing number of them are run by diaspora
Indians? Why do Indian students go abroad for an expensive first-rate
education in universities full of Indian professors teaching them? Why
cannot Indian universities, other than a handful, offer such quality education?
Services, including IT, media, research, education and healthcare, now
drive economic growth globally. Diaspora Indians link the Indian to the
global service sectors. Their expertise and business acumen could transform
India into a dominant exporter of services just like overseas Chinese
helped transform China into a global exporter of goods. That can only
happen if India reforms rules and practices in each sector to dismantle
the barriers keeping diaspora Indians away. It means tackling the vested
interests that deter the diaspora from building more schools and universities,
setting up medical facilities, and investing in India.
A recently established business school in Hyderabad is a rare successful
example of the potential contribution of Indians abroad. It is also the
exception that proves the rule. Most attempts to set up institutions of
higher education involving foreign partners have been blocked by a lethal
combination of bad rules, political resistance, and professional jealousy.
It is not enough, however, to create a few elite institutions or open
a few sectors like IT to the global market. India needs to act boldly,
pushing for liberalization of services at the global level and working
with ethnic Indians abroad and other governments to lower trade barriers
and strengthen business practices to attract more investment.
|