|

|
| THE MESS: The historic Oval Maidan was overrun
by drug pushers, sex workers and antisocials. Political protestors
took over whatever street space was left by hawkers. |
|

|
| THE VIGILANTES: Punj (left) and Kathpalia fought
a relentless battle to clear the area and restore to it the status
of a green belt. |
Till a year
ago, the Oval Maidan in Mumbai was an eyesore. This heritage site was
a haven for drug pushers, pimps, sex workers, card sharps and all sorts
of antisocials. Morchas headed for Mantralaya were a daily nuisance and
virtually every inch of the pavement opposite Churchgate Station was usurped
by hawkers leaving pedestrians with no space to walk. In other words Oval
Maidan was not what it was meant to be-a much-needed green belt for residents
in south Mumbai.
A fact that disturbed Neera Punj, Nayana Kathpalia and Kunti Oza very
much. Punj, after a long stint abroad, had returned to live near Churchgate,
and Kathpalia, an activist with intach in Delhi, had shifted base to Mumbai
where her home faced the historic Oval Maidan. Oza had lived all her life
in the city. The three enterprising women rallied around to set things
right. It wasn't easy. They were mocked at, officials were amused and
dismissed these 'English-speaking mems'. But the committed trio, fully
aware of their rights, knocked at the doors of the Brihanmumbai Municipal
Corporation (BMC), local government representatives and finally the Bombay
High Court-all this in the late 1990s.
Their relentless crusade eventually paid off. Today morchas have been
banned in the area and are stopped at Azad Maidan, the Oval Maidan has
been restored to its pristine glory and pedestrians are able to walk on
the pavements opposite Churchgate. Success breeds success. The three are
now much sought after for guidance and help by residents' groups spread
across the city. Their initiative-Citizens Forum for Protection of Public
Space, better known as CitiSpace-now has over 500 paid members who are
consulted by the BMC each time an issue of open space arises in the city.
As Punj says, "If citizens wish to improve the quality of life around
them, they can do it. But they have to step out."
Citizens are indeed stepping out. In a departure from the past, Mumbaikars
aren't resigning to their fate or escaping to the suburbs. Worsening civic
and environmental conditions and burgeoning corruption in Mumbai have
nudged citizens across the city out of their slumber. They have come together
in groups to raise issues and fight for their rights.
|

|
| THE MESS: Mumbaikars were choked by a cloud
of pollution in traffic-clogged streets. The corrosive compounds in
the air caused, among others, asthma. |
|

|
| THE VIGILANTES: Rane and others went to court
and got it to direct the government to implement pollution norms and
prescribe punitive steps. |
Over 1,500 different groups are active across the city. Gerson da Cunha,
convenor of Agni (Action for Good Governance and Networking in India),
points out that over 1,000 street committees maintain complaint registers
and monitor problems as diverse as air quality, water supply, garbage
collection, noise pollution, space management, road maintenance and, of
course, corruption in public offices. The urban vigilantes are today a
growing breed.
George Gopali is one of them. Eight years ago, disgusted by the sight
of plastic bags littering Mumbai's famous Juhu beach, he wondered if the
stretch of sand could become as clean as some of the beaches abroad. A
little help from the then municipal commissioner Sharad Kale spurred Gopali
and he started cleaning up the waterfronts. His efforts paid off. Gopali's
initiative could well become the first of its kind to translate into a
viable business proposition.
If Gopali wanted to see cleaner beaches, there were others gasping for
cleaner air. Every day Sandeep Rane, a cardiologist living in the north-eastern
suburb of Chembur, came across several patients affected by the rising
vehicular pollution. In another part of the city, Meher Rafat found her
daughter Shanaya's asthmatic condition worsening due to the corrosive
pollutants in the air. Every friend and doctor she met had only one suggestion:
leave Mumbai. Rafat, an easygoing Parsi on most days, was riled. The common
thought in Rane's and her mind was: something had to be done.
Echoing similar sentiments were H.N. Daruwala, who works with the Godrej
Group, businessman Prabhu Raveshia and a host of others. Rane filed a
public-interest petition against the state Government. The result was
a landmark judgement where the Bombay High Court came down heavily on
the Maharashtra Government and directed it to implement pollution control
norms and levy heavy fines, cancel registration and prosecute drivers.
Even though the battle is still on, at least Shanaya and millions of Mumbaikars
can breathe a little easier now.
Most often activism stems from inaction and by harassed citizens who
could not take it anymore. Every monsoon, the homes of residents in Guzdar
Baug in Mumbai's Santa Cruz area were flooded, thanks to the encroachment
of a nearby mangrove by a slum lord. Navin Mithal, a flight engineer with
Air-India, couldn't take it any longer. Says Mithal: "On one side
was the inaction of the BMC and on the other the threats by the goons
of the slumlord." A tired and disgusted Mithal finally approached
the court. In a landmark judgement in October 2001, 8,000 hutments were
ordered to be shifted and the BMC was asked to clean and desilt the sewers.
|

|
| THE MESS: Every monsoon, houses in Guzdar Baug
in the Santa Cruz area were flooded because of encroachments on the
once-extensive mangrove nearby. |
|

|
| THE VIGILANTE: Risking the anger of landsharks,
Mithal went to court and won a verdict against the 8,000 illegal hutments. |
Karun Srivastava, commissioner of the BMC, feels there has been a welcome
tangible change with public organisations not just complaining and confronting
but taking up responsibilities as well. Says Srivastava: "Public
watchdog cells are absolutely necessary. They work as pressure points,
which makes the officers more alert and responsible."
That's precisely what groups like the Vigilance Advisory Committee do.
This forum formed by R.H. Mendonca, Satish Sawhney and Arvind Inamdar,
all former police commissioners, and former cabinet secretary B.G. Deshmukh
spearheads the battle against corruption. Mendonca got the idea following
the success of the Vigilance Awareness Week held in Mumbai in 2001. The
aim, says Mendonca modestly, is to "provide a bridge between civil
society and officials and act as a catalyst in fighting corruption".
Significantly, often the activists are not politically connected nor
are they social workers. They are just ordinary people: professionals,
businessmen, housewives and even retired bureaucrats and police officials
who share similar ideals. Like Bhagwanji Raiyani, a builder-developer
and resident of Vile Parle, who recently discovered that a builder had
usurped prime public land meant for new premises for various courts and
tribunals in the suburb of Malad. He filed a public interest petition
and won the case. While disposing the case Chief Justice B.P. Singh and
Justice D.Y. Chandrachud thanked Raiyani "for his interest and alertness
in raising the issue before the court".
Most often the activism leads to public-interest petitions and ends
up at the Bombay High Court. Advocate M.P. Vashi, a founder-member of
the public organisation Jan Hit Manch, which takes up social issues and
fights them, believes public interest petitions are not the answer for
they are time-consuming and unaffordable. Vashi personally appears in
at least two public-interest cases and lends a ear to some 100 people
who visit his office every day. "When doctors and lawyers are busy,
it means society is in trouble," says Vashi, adding that "today
only injections seem to work on personal health and injunctions on societal
health".
Deshmukh feels there is an urgent need for change. The rising need for
citizens' activism, he believes, "definitely points to a failure
of the administrative machinery". One of the problems faced by various
groups is inadequate involvement of the elected representatives. And this
is what Mayank Gandhi and Sudipt Sen are seeking to set right. The duo
spend their evenings speaking to voters in Jogeshwari and Vile Parle about
the forthcoming municipal polls. One would think they are candidates or
party workers, but Gandhi, an exporter, and Sen, a pilot, are members
of the K West Citizens' Association. Their mission: to urge people to
step out and vote for clean and competent candidates.
Agni too has initiated a programme to educate voters to bring about
this change. Mumbaikars from every walk of life and those who belong to
groups like Citispace, Clean Mumbai Foundation, Dignity Foundation, Nagar,
Power, Proud and others have come under the Agni umbrella to campaign
for citizens' rights and better governance. Mumbaikars are not expecting
miracles but as Deshmukh says, "If a cause is worth doing then it
is worth the first step." The urban vigilantes in Mumbai are taking
that first step.
|