Sonia
Gandhi brushes aside critics to make her speech at the Oxford Centre
for Islamic Studies.
WEB
ONLY FEATURES
Having discarded the AIADMK's Dravidian
roots, Jayalalithaa is out to overshadow the MGR legacy. India Today's Arun
Ram traces the path of her untiring ambition. Iconic
Change
INDIA
TODAY CONCLAVE
The
Conclave concludes on a high note. Al Gore, Stanley Fischer and other world
leaders listen and are heard. Catch up on the highlights. Take
me to Conclave now
CARE
TODAY
INDIA
TODAY HINDI
CURRENT
ISSUE DECEMBER 16, 2002
STATES: KARNATAKA
Downhill Yatra
Even as he
fails to free Nagappa or put an end to the Cauvery crisis, fresh rows with
neighbouring states threaten to further destabilise Krishna
by
Stephen David
Profiles
in Courage. It is no coincidence that Karnataka Chief Minister S.M. Krishna
is reading the John F. Kennedy masterpiece. As he candidly points out,
the lives of the American heroes in the Pulitzer Prize-winning book are
very inspiring. And inspiration is something he desperately needs at the
moment.
When he took over the reins of power on October
11, 1999, Krishna was a picture of enterprise. Aware of the software sector's
potential in which Bangalore already had a headstart, he sought to synergise
infotech with polity. He got his officials laptops, walked into the computer
science department of the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, one
morning to learn the basics of PowerPoint presentation, threw out dust-laden
files and moth-eaten papers and installed gadgets in his third-floor office
in the Vidhana Soudha. Riding the crest of a popularity wave, he barked
orders to faraway district collectors using video-conference facilities.
Clearly, he wanted to give his Andhra Pradesh counterpart N. Chandrababu
Naidu a run for his neo-techie image.
INTERVIEW: S.M. KRISHNA
"Even US can't catch Osama"
Karnataka Chief Minister
S.M. Krishna speaks to Principal Correspondent stephen david on the
crises surrounding his administration. Excerpts:
Q. You are neck-deep in problems-the border tension,
Cauvery issue, Nagappa crisis, allegation that the Government paid
Rs 20 crore to Veerappan.
A. Challenges only come to those who have the guts to face them.
As Martin Luther King said, "We shall overcome."
Q. You compared the hunt for Veerappan to the search for Osama
bin Laden.
A. I was making the point that it is difficult for even a superpower
to catch bin Laden. We have not captured Veerappan because of the
tough terrain. I am also disgusted with the way some of the stf
chiefs have conducted themselves.
Q. Former Karnataka police chief C. Dinakar says you paid Rs
20 crore as ransom to Veerappan to free Rajkumar.
A. The allegations are nothing new. These have been made by
Tamil Nadu too. Perhaps this man's roots in that state are still
very strong.
Q. Dinakar has named you personally in the book.
A. Since he has named me personally, it is going to be S.M.
Krishna who will initiate action and not the chief minister.
Q. Have you read the book?
A. No, whatever I have read is from the newspapers. I don't
want to read a book written by someone who has totally betrayed
my confidence.
Q. Are you facing pressure from within the party?
A. No, I have the support of the Congress high command.
Krishna's efforts did not go unnoticed: twice
he was voted India's best chief minister in opinion polls conducted by
india today. Three years down the line, the gung-ho spirit has given way
to ennui. So what went wrong? "He may be a good man," says bjp
leader Jagadish Shettar, "but he has become weak. There is no second
in command and most of his ministers and bureaucrats are colourless."
The earlier phalanx of do-gooders has simply disappeared.
The 71-year-old chief minister is suddenly finding
himself on a sticky wicket. "Krishna's problems are both manmade
and natural," says Janata Dal leader C. Byre Gowda. "The drought
that worsened the Cauvery crisis may have been beyond his control, but
the failure to nab Veerappan on time did him in." Two years ago,
when the infamous outlaw held Kannada matinee idol Rajkumar hostage for
108 days, Krishna should have put pressure on the police to hem him in.
Today, he remains exasperatingly elusive, more than 100 days since kidnapping
former Janata Dal leader Hanur Nagappa from his farmhouse near Mysore.
Nagappa's release may be possible only after jailed
Tamil activist Kolathur Mani treks to the forest as the Government's unofficial
envoy, as demanded by Veerappan. But even though Mani is yet to get bail
in two cases, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister J. Jayalalithaa threatens to ruin
Krishna's plans. She says she will arrest Mani if he steps into Tamil
Nadu territory, even if it is to negotiate with Veerappan.
Krishna's irritation over the failure to arrest
Veerappan is evident. "I must admit the failure of the police force.
They tell me Veerappan is operating in an 18,000 sq km area, a terrain
our men find extremely difficult to comb" (See interview). Krishna
is now even contemplating disbanding the 12-year-old Special Task Force
that has failed to achieve its mission of catching Veerappan. "It's
very disturbing," he says. It shows on him. His security adviser
on Veerappan affairs, former state police chief T. Srinivasalu, is planning
to give him a report on the stf on which nearly Rs 40 crore has been spent
so far.
Things would have been manageable if his troubles
had ended there. But last month, another former state police chief C.
Dinakar alleged, in his book Veerappan's Prize Catch, that Krishna paid
a ransom of Rs 20 crore to the outlaw to secure Rajkumar's release. Krishna
says he is considering legal action against Dinakar, but the former police
chief is unperturbed. "What I have written is the truth. Let me see
what action they can take against me," he says defiantly.
The bureaucracy could be the millstone around
Krishna's neck-by his own admission "a rather heavy burden".
Trusted aide and principal secretary for more than three years, S.V. Ranganath
voluntarily moved to the Centre as joint secretary in the Indian Space
Research Organisation in Bangalore. Krishna's chief secretary, A. Ravindra,
like most of the 250-odd ias officers in Karnataka, hasn't pitched in
effectively. Those who have shown results can be counted on the fingertips:
Commissioner Jayakar Jerome, who has turned the bleeding Bangalore Development
Authority into a Rs 300 crore cash chest; Additional Revenue Secretary
Rajeev Chawla who has been spearheading the Bhoomi project-computerisation
of land records for farmers; Tourism Commissioner I.M. Vittalamurthy,
and to some extent Vivek Kulkarni and Ramana Reddy who have been trying
to keep the infotech and biotech flags flying high.
On Krishna's platter
Tamil Grievances * Kannada groups ban cinema halls from screening Tamil films.
* Ban on Tamil TV channels in Karnataka.
* Delay in unveiling the statue of Tamil poet Thiruvalluvar in Bangalore.
Cauvery Dispute * Farmers in Mandya and Maddur agitate against the apex court's
order to release Cauvery waters to Tamil Nadu.
* Krishna defies order, goes on a padyatra.
* The apex court is yet to resolve the contempt case against Krishna.
Veerappan Saga * The outlaw kidnaps former minister Nagappa.
* Krishna agrees to free jailed Tamil activist Mani to free Nagappa.
* Jayalalitha threatens to arrest Mani if he sets foot in Tamil Nadu;
approach to the jungles from Karnataka difficult.
Mahajan Report * Maharashtra contests the Mahajan recommendations (central to
border dispute); threatens to go to court.
* Pro-Kannada groups ask the Centre to implement the report that is
in Karnataka's favour.
Krishna
Waters
* Andhra Pradesh wants a new tribunal to settle the issue of sharing
the Krishna river waters.
* Karnataka says large-scale projects in Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh
use surplus water, putting interests of Karnataka farmers at risk.
There are darts flying from all sides. Krishna's
handling of the century-old dispute over sharing of the Cauvery waters
has put him in a tight spot. He is yet to recover from the folly of disobeying
the Supreme Court order on releasing water to Tamil Nadu. The apex court
is yet to resolve the contempt case against him and his team of ministers
but farmers in Krishna's home district, Mandya, have threatened to fan
the flames on the Cauvery issue. Farmers in his assembly constituency
Maddur were up in arms after he decided to release water to Tamil Nadu.
A 100-km padyatra that he undertook from Bangalore to Mandya did little
to redeem things.
The chief minister also has to fend off barbs
from Andhra Pradesh which is demanding a share of the Krishna river water.
The tdp Government has urged the Centre to constitute a fresh tribunal
as the term of the Bachawat Tribunal expired in May 2000. It wants allocations
among riparian states to be fixed, with full rights over surplus water,
besides protection of its share awarded by the previous tribunal. Telugu
Desam MPs have cautioned the Centre of dangerous consequences if the water-sharing
problem is not solved.
There's bedlam on the Maharashtra border too.
The state's Congress-led coalition Government has approached the Supreme
Court on the border dispute-an issue which Karnataka has dismissed as
a "closed chapter" following the recommendations of the Mahajan
Commission in the 1967. "It is a dead issue and is raised from time
to time by people with ulterior motives," says Krishna. Kannada rights
leader Vatal Nagaraj, who is also the Border Area Study Commission chairman,
has sought an all-party meeting to assess the situation. Kannada activist
Patil Puttappa says Marathi organisations such as the Shiv Sena and the
Marathi Ekkikaran Samiti are trying to create a pro-Maharashtra feeling
among Kannadigas living in the border villages which, according to the
Mahajan Commission report, belong to Karnataka.
Krishna is the target of opposition parties in
Karnataka which have been warning him that after having allegedly "failed"
to protect the state's interests on Cauvery, he should do all he can to
safeguard their interests on the boundary issue. "There is no dispute
with Maharashtra," says Krishna, but in villages in Belgaum district
bordering Maharashtra the tension between Marathi- and Kannada-speaking
groups is palpable.
THE ALLEGATIONS
Karnataka Chief Minister S.M. Krishna paid
a ransom of Rs 20 crore to Veerappan to free matinee idol Rajkumar
and end the 108-day hostage drama.
Among those who delivered the money were Krishna's
son-in-law V.G. Siddhartha (Rs 10 crore), IGP (Intelligence) T.
Jayaprakash Rs 5 crore and Rajkumar's wife Parvathamma Rs 1 crore.
After the deal was made Krishna spoke to Veerappan
on a mobile phone and the brigand confirmed the release of Rajkumar
and two other hostages.
Ransom report: Dinakar says he
has enough evidence to prove his point
Krishna says Karnataka is "prepared and equipped"
to fight Maharashtra in the Supreme Court. "The issue can be settled
once and for all if the Mahajan Commission report is accepted as final
by the two states as well as the Centre," he says. "There is
no dispute. What is pending is the scrupulous implementation of the report,"
says Krishna.
Contrary to Krishna's promise of giving more "teeth"
to the lok ayukta to curb corruption, on November 22 the state Cabinet
rejected a recommendation from Lok Ayukta Justice (retd) N. Venkatachala
to bring employees of the state legislature under his purview and to scrap
the independent jurisdiction of the lok ayukta and upalok ayukta. He had
suggested a centralised structure in which any case pending before the
upalok ayukta could be withdrawn by the lok ayukta for investigation.
At the moment, the beleaguered chief minister
is hoping for a break-and that is likely only if the kidnapped Nagappa
walks out of the jungles a free man. He has been so busy fending off one
crisis after another that Krishna-president of the Karnataka Lawn Tennis
Association-has hardly found time to wield the racket. Last week he showed
up at Bangalore's St Mark's Cathedral for Davis Cupper Mahesh Bhupathi's
wedding with model Shveta Jaishankar before flying off to Gujarat to campaign
along with party President Sonia Gandhi.
"He is a capable man but he is slipping,"
says former chief minister and fellow art-lover Ramakrishna Hegde. But
Krishna has too many things on his plate. Too many battles to fight. He
isn't losing heart though. "We shall overcome some day," he
says, taking refuge in the words of another American-Martin Luther King.