Jan 25, 1999
|
|
|
|
Atal's
Trojan Mares A Government where everybody is a brake can never be a self-starter.
There are a few points which the lady needs to clarify. One, by rejecting ministries like surface transport as "inconsequential", is she implying that her state has perfect roads and, in fact, faces no problems other than incomplete railway projects? Two, it may not have occurred to Mamata, but surely South Block is the seat of the Government of India rather than that of West Bengal? There is a difference between regionalism and reductionism. By being primarily responsible -- sundry forces within the BJP and in other allied parties also did their bit -- for postponing the reshuffle, Mamata and Jayalalitha have yet again called the coalition's political management skills into question. Vajpayee's recalcitrant allies would do well to recall the denouement of the United Front (UF) soap opera, 1996-98: the UF prime ministers are non-entities -- but most of their prickly juniors are not doing any better. Outrage in Kalinga Anjana Mishra's charges require quick inquiry-not politicisation.
In all this the truth has been forgotten. Actually, it interests none. Are Mishra's allegations true? If they are, is the police any closer to arresting her assailants? Is Bhubaneswar increasingly unsafe for women? Nobody in the Government -- actually, in any political party -- seems bothered. As a similar incident in Jaipur a year ago made clear, a rape victim for India's politicians is no more than a political issue, scarcely different from a corruption case. If rape is evil, such insensitivity is vile. It is nobody's argument that the political class' mores can be transformed overnight. Even so, a start could be made if the judicial commission set up to investigate Mishra's charges is told to submit its report expeditiously, in a month at the most. Meanwhile, Patnaik and his friends should stop prejudging the matter and simply shut up. |
|
Issue Contents | Write to us | Subscriptions | Syndication BUSINESS TODAY | INDIA TODAY PLUS | COMPUTERS TODAY © Living Media India Ltd |
 |
 |
For everything that is true of India,
somebody once exclaimed, the opposite is also true. Take the cabinet form of government.
In theory, the prime minister has the unfettered right to choose his colleagues. In
reality, as Atal Bihari Vajpayee came to realise this past week, the prime minister can do
anything but that. Some lobbying is to be expected when a cabinet reshuffle is in the
offing. What is not on is the division of the Cabinet into little territories, each with
its own mini-prime minister -- self-appointed and outside the government. J. Jayalalitha,
for instance, has taken it upon herself to decide which Tamil MP will become a minister
and which one will be dropped, trifles such as competence be damned. She has also declared
certain portfolios her monopoly. Since playing termagant is the flavour of the season,
Mamata Banerjee has come up with her own preposterous demands. Having consistently refused
to allow her Trinamool Congress to join the Vajpayee Government, she now says she will but
only if given the Railway Ministry. Her reason: the ministry can help West Bengal. 
Rape, behavioural scientists have often
stressed, has less to do with sexuality than with an assertion of power. In India rape is
about power alright -- political power. On January 9 Anjana Mishra, a lady who had earlier
accused a former advocate general of Orissa and friend of Chief Minister J.B. Patnaik of
molestation, was waylaid and subjected to further assault. The criminals, she said, seemed
to know who she was and scoffed at her battle against the ruling establishment.
Expectedly, the repeated violation of Mishra has jolted Orissa. There have been public
protests, admittedly with some political instigation but nevertheless representative of
mass anger. That Patnaik himself has disbelieved Mishra's story and responded with
innuendoes rather than firmness has not helped. The most disgusting reaction has come from
within the ruling Congress. Dissidents have used the incident to file sanctimonious
complaints with the party president. Their inspiration? Patnaik's deputy chief minister
who is angling for his boss' job. 
