In many ways Elaben is an enigma and an anachronism
in today's world. A favourite on the international lecture
circuit, she is particularly sought after by those groups
who are considered radical, progressive, liberal and
anti-establishment. By those who challenge the high
and mighty economic monoliths, the lovers of "small
is beautiful", those who make themselves feel good as
people with the right kind of conscience. The Gandhian's
soft voice, traditional simplicity and stories of how
one or the other sister gained empowerment in a village
community make the sterile auditoriums and lives of
western liberals gain meaning through their vicarious
association with her grassroots work.
How
has the world benefited from Elaben's contributions?
Has India done its bit for her and dropped her? Has
the media decided that Gandhian workers are not glamorous
enough to match neo-celebrities like Bina Ramani and
Nafisa Ali? Is society uncaring or does Elaben's work
lack the punch that makes people sit up? An honest answer
is a bit of both.
Best
known for founding the Self-Employed Women's Association
(SEWA), her pioneering work has been in creating institutions
through which the lowest rungs of working women become
self-reliant. The idea of trade unionism in the self-employed
sector is difficult enough as it is. To be a woman breaking
away from the grip of an established trade union in
which men ran the show was a bold step by which she
created her own paths and methods of organisation. That
she did it without militancy and aggressive rhetoric
was unusual in itself and that these became models for
international institutions and NGOs is further proof
of the efficacy of her actions.
Bhatt
received much recognition for her work between 1977
and 1987. In India and around the world, democracy in
its purer form, idealism in world politics, moral values
in political strategies were still around. Those years
in India covered the post-Jayaprakash Narayan phase
when volunteerism was a new form of social work. NGOs
were expected to raise awareness, lobby for people's
rights, do constructive work for development and, most
importantly, were not expected to buck the system beyond
a point. The establishment was supposed to respond to
them positively out of the goodness of its non-existent
heart.
Elaben's
trade union work seemed more akin to NGO activity and
was therefore found more acceptable to those who wielded
power. In fact, she became a showpiece for the establishment.
She created new spaces and terms for women's work without
really pushing the vested interests out of business.
At the same time she did not extend herself or her agenda
beyond a limited horizon.
In
the early '90s when the so-called developing nations
of Asia and Africa succumbed to the prescriptions of
GATT and a more heartless economic order, Elaben stayed
away from the unified protest actions of both the trade
unions and the NGOs in India. SEWA women did not participate
in these "people's movements", which was a setback for
them.
Elaben's
work and her institutions have been models that have
been replicated only half-heartedly, with no effective
results. Her involvement and contribution to the preparation
of the Shram Shakti report in the mid-'80s on working
women all over India is an invaluable reference document
which now needs updating. Instead of using the political
system to effectively lobbying or struggle for better
rights for working women, Elaben has chosen to limit
her field of action even while she shares her ideas
and experience across the globe.
The
relevance of her work is even greater now, yet most
chose to applaud but not to imitate her. In a world
where the politics of power dominates, Elaben's woman-power
needs to move back centrestage and play a more challenging
rather than a demonstrative role.
Jaya Jaitly is
secretary, Samata Party. She is also a women's rights
activist and president, Dastkari Haat Samiti.